文献速递儿童呼吸儿童感染

乌干达从木炭向电炊具过渡的儿童健康影响:一项定性利益相关者研究

Child health implications of transitioning from charcoal to electric cooking in Uganda: a qualitative stakeholder study
RSS 订阅 · BMJ Paediatrics Open

该定性研究于2023年9月至11月在坎帕拉对51名参与电炊具推广、监管、研究、融资和实施的乌干达政策与能源领域利益相关者进行结构化访谈,采用Creswell六步定性分析法。利益相关者认为电炊具比木炭更安全且与减少烟雾暴露和炊事相关危害有关,但儿童健康益处多为间接且取决于能源与政策系统条件;主要障碍包括电力基础设施不可靠、电器前期成本高、电费可负担性担忧、政策框架碎片化和根深蒂固的社会文化烹饪习惯,儿童健康考量很少被明确列为能源或清洁烹饪政策的驱动因素。

要点

  • 利益相关者认为电炊具比木炭更安全,与减少烟雾暴露和炊事相关危害有关。
  • 儿童健康益处被视为 largely 间接且取决于能源与政策系统层面条件。
  • 主要障碍包括电力不可靠、电器前期成本高、电费可负担性担忧、政策碎片化和烹饪习惯。

核心结论

  • 政策利益相关者认为电炊具是减少乌干达儿童暴露于家庭空气污染和炊事相关伤害的有前景的上游儿童健康干预措施。
  • 实现这些儿童健康益处需要改善电力可靠性、提高电炊具技术的可负担性并将儿童健康目标明确纳入能源和清洁烹饪政策。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用结构化访谈的定性利益相关者研究,纳入51名参与乌干达电炊具推广、监管、研究、融资和实施的政策的与能源领域利益相关者。
  • 参与者从政府、发展伙伴、民间社会组织、私营部门、学术机构和有经验终端用户中目的性抽样。
  • 数据于2023年9月至11月在坎帕拉收集,采用Creswell六步定性分析方法分析,报告遵循定性研究统一报告标准(COREQ)。

主要发现

  • 利益相关者认为电炊具比木炭更安全,并与减少烟雾暴露和炊事相关危害相关。
  • 潜在的儿童健康益处,尤其是减少家庭空气污染暴露和炊事相关伤害,被视为 largely 间接且取决于能源和政策系统层面条件。
  • 关键障碍包括电力基础设施不可靠、电器前期成本高、对电费可负担性的担忧、政策框架碎片化和根深蒂固的社会文化烹饪习惯。
  • 儿童健康考量很少被描述为能源或清洁烹饪政策的明确驱动因素。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Background Household air pollution and cooking-related injuries from charcoal use remain major contributors to preventable child morbidity and mortality in low- and middle-income countries, including Uganda. Electric cooking (e-cooking) could reduce children’s exposure to these risks, yet adoption remains limited and the policy conditions shaping this transition are poorly understood from a child health perspective. Objective To explore policy stakeholder perspectives on transitioning from charcoal to e-cooking in Uganda and to examine perceived implications for child health related to household air pollution and cooking-related injuries. Methods We conducted a qualitative stakeholder study using structured interviews with 51 policy and energy-sector stakeholders involved in e-cooking promotion, regulation, research, financing and implementation in Uganda. Participants were purposively sampled from government, development partners, civil society organisations, the private sector, academic institutions and experienced end users. Data were collected in Kampala between September and November 2023 and analysed using Creswell’s six-step qualitative analysis approach. Reporting followed the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research. Results Stakeholders perceived e-cooking as safer than charcoal and associated with reduced smoke exposure and cooking-related hazards. However, potential child health benefits, particularly reduced exposure to household air pollution and cooking-related injuries, are viewed as largely indirect and contingent on energy and policy system-level conditions. Key barriers included unreliable electricity infrastructure, high upfront appliance costs, concerns about electricity affordability, fragmented policy frameworks and entrenched sociocultural cooking practices. Child health considerations were rarely described as explicit drivers of energy or clean cooking policy. Conclusions E-cooking is viewed by policy stakeholders as a promising upstream child health intervention to reduce children’s exposure to household air pollution and cooking-related injuries in Uganda. Realising these child health benefits will require improved electricity reliability, greater affordability of e-cooking technologies and explicit integration of child health objectives into energy and clean cooking policy.

来源:BMJ Paediatrics Open,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. BMJ Paediatrics Open:Child health implications of transitioning from charcoal to electric cooking in Uganda: a qualitative stakeholder study

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。