成骨不全是否使婴儿易患干骺端骨折?系统综述
该系统综述检索Medline、CINAHL和Web of Science,旨在明确2岁以下成骨不全(OI)患儿干骺端骨折的患病率,最终仅纳入4篇文章。结论认为OI易致婴幼儿干骺端骨折的证据有限,两种诊断并不互斥,即使确诊OI,干骺端骨折婴幼儿仍须始终考虑身体虐待可能。
要点
- 2岁以下OI患儿干骺端骨折的现有证据有限,仅4篇文章符合纳入标准。
- OI与干骺端骨折并非互斥,确诊OI不能排除身体虐待。
- 干骺端骨折婴幼儿即使确诊OI,也应始终考虑身体虐待可能。
核心结论
- OI易使婴幼儿发生干骺端骨折的证据有限。
- OI与干骺端骨折两种诊断并不互斥。
- 在开展进一步大型研究前,干骺端骨折婴幼儿即使确诊OI也应始终考虑身体虐待。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索Medline、CINAHL和Web of Science。
- 纳入报告2岁以下OI患儿干骺端骨折的研究。
- 排除无法获取全文、非英文发表或未定义/图示「干骺端」骨折的文章。
- 使用Critical Appraisal Skills Programme和Case Reports工具独立评估文献质量。
主要发现
- 检索到298篇摘要,其中82篇为重复,216篇经标题和摘要筛选后排除186篇。
- 对剩余30篇文章手工检索另发现2篇,最终仅4篇纳入。
- 一篇报告中41例1日龄至3岁OI患儿有4例存在「干骺端」骨折。
- 一篇病例系列报告一名16月龄男孩有三处「干骺端」骨折,尽管诊断为IV型OI(未基因确认)仍存在虐待担忧。
- 一篇报告一名7月龄女孩有两处「角」骨折,疑诊OI并疑遭虐待;另一篇报告一对同胞兄妹有「干骺端」骨折及XI型OI(FKBP10突变)。
临床怎么用
- 临床遇婴幼儿干骺端骨折时,即使已确诊OI,也应始终考虑身体虐待可能。
- 不应将OI诊断作为排除干骺端骨折虐待病因的依据。
局限性
- 符合纳入标准的研究仅4篇,证据量有限。
- 原文未报告所纳入研究的样本量汇总、偏倚风险量化结果或合并效应量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective The notion that osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) predisposes children to metaphyseal fractures is controversial. This review aimed to ascertain the prevalence of metaphyseal fractures in children with OI less than 2 years of age. Materials and methods Medline, CINAHL and Web of Science were searched for studies reporting metaphyseal fractures in children with OI less than 2 years of age. Articles not retrievable, not published in English, or where ‘metaphyseal’ fracture was not defined/illustrated, were excluded. Article quality was independently assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme and Case Reports tools. Results Of 298 retrieved abstracts, 82 were duplicates: 216 articles were screened by title and abstract, excluding 186. Hand search of the remaining 30 articles identified two further articles. Only four articles were included: (1) 4/41 children with OI aged between 1 day and 3 years with ‘metaphyseal’ fractures; (2) a case series including a 16-month-old boy with three ‘metaphyseal’ fractures. Abuse concerns remained despite a type IV OI diagnosis (not genetically confirmed); (3) a 7-month-old girl with two ‘corner’ fractures suspected to have OI and to have been abused; and (4) a pair of siblings with ‘metaphyseal’ fractures and type XI OI ( FKBP10 mutation). Conclusions There is limited evidence that OI predisposes infants and young children to metaphyseal fractures. The two diagnoses are not mutually exclusive and until further large studies are conducted, physical abuse should always be considered in infants and young children with metaphyseal fractures, even in those with confirmed OI.
引用
- BMJ Paediatrics Open:Does osteogenesis imperfecta predispose infants to metaphyseal fractures? A systematic review
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。