文献速递儿童感染儿童神经与发育行为

提升荷兰急诊科儿童虐待与忽视筛查工具(SCAN)的实施与依从性

Enhancing implementation and compliance of the Screening Instrument for Child Abuse and Neglect (SCAN) in emergency departments in the Netherlands
RSS 订阅 · BMJ Paediatrics Open

本研究在荷兰九家急诊科实施SCAN与STEPS工具,评估实施能否提升筛查依从性及工具可用性。实施后平均依从率从57.5%升至70.5%,8家机构中3家达到≥10%的临床相关改善;可用性分析识别出五个促进因素和一个障碍因素。作者认为SCAN&STEPS可改善儿童虐待识别依从性,但需量身定制策略并进一步验证国际适用性。

要点

  • 实施后平均依从率从57.5%升至70.5%,8家机构中3家改善≥10%。
  • 大学医院急诊科改善幅度最高,依从性受电子健康记录配置影响。
  • 可用性分析识别五个促进因素(如责任感、社会支持)和一个障碍因素(组织不稳定)。

核心结论

  • SCAN&STEPS可提升急诊科对儿童虐待关注的筛查依从性,但需量身定制策略以进一步实施。
  • 标准化方法有助于统一数据收集,促进比较分析和跨学科协作,推进儿童虐待早期识别。
  • 更广泛的国际采用应考虑政策和系统层面差异,并需进一步验证以确保荷兰以外适用性。

研究设计与样本

  • 在九家急诊科将SCAN&STEPS嵌入工作流程和电子健康记录,并配套电子学习、政策手册和意识宣传活动等实施策略。
  • 通过比较实施前后SCAN筛查率评估有效性,以≥10%增幅定义为临床相关。
  • 采用混合方法设计评估可用性,结合创新决定因素测量工具和半结构式访谈。
  • 按医院类型、电子健康记录、专业和工作年限进行亚组分析。

主要发现

  • 实施后平均依从率从57.5%升至70.5%,8家机构中3家达到≥10%改善。
  • 依从率因机构而异,大学医院急诊科改善最高。
  • 依从性受电子健康记录配置影响。
  • 可用性分析识别五个促进因素:责任感、社会支持、自我效能、知识和正式管理认可;一个障碍因素:组织不稳定。
  • 使用者认为SCAN&STEPS用户友好,但护士和医生因角色相关因素感知支持存在差异。

关键数值与推荐

  • SCAN筛查依从率实施后平均为70.5%,实施前为57.5%。
  • 临床相关改善定义为筛查率增加≥10%,8家机构中3家达到。

临床怎么用

  • 可将SCAN&STEPS嵌入急诊科工作流程和电子健康记录以提升儿童虐待筛查依从性。
  • 实施时需配套电子学习、政策手册和意识宣传等策略。
  • 应关注电子健康记录配置对依从性的影响,并针对护士和医生角色差异提供支持。
  • 需针对组织不稳定等障碍因素制定量身定制策略。

局限性

  • 研究仅在荷兰九家急诊科进行,国际适用性需进一步验证。
  • 原文未报告样本量、P值等详细统计信息。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Study purpose This study examines the implementation of the Screening Instrument for Child Abuse and Neglect (SCAN) and the Structured Tool for Evaluating Positive Screened cases (STEPS) in nine emergency departments (EDs). The study aimed to assess whether implementation could enhance compliance with SCAN and to evaluate the usability of SCAN&STEPS within an implementation-focused design, in response to the decline in child maltreatment recognition observed in Dutch EDs over the past decade. Methods SCAN&STEPS was embedded in ED workflow and electronic health records (EHRs), supported by a selection of implementation strategies, including e-learning, policy manuals and an awareness campaign. Effectiveness was assessed through compliance with SCAN, comparing preimplementation and postimplementation screening rates, with a ≥10% increase defined as clinically relevant. Usability of SCAN&STEPS was examined using a mixed-method design combining the Measurement Instrument for Determinants of Innovations and semistructured interviews. Subgroup analyses were conducted by hospital type, EHR, profession and years of working experience. Results After implementation, the average compliance rate increased from 57.5% to 70.5%, with 3 of 8 sites achieving ≥10% improvement. Rates varied by site, with university hospital EDs having the highest improvement. Compliance was influenced by EHR configurations. Usability analysis identified five facilitators (perception of responsibility, social support, self-efficacy, knowledge and formal management ratification) and one barrier (unsettled organisation). Users considered SCAN&STEPS user-friendly, though perceived support differed between nurses and physicians due to role-specific factors. Relevance SCAN&STEPS can improve compliance in recognising child maltreatment concerns, but tailored strategies are needed for further implementation in Dutch hospitals. The standardised approach enhances uniform data collection, enabling comparative analysis and interdisciplinary collaboration, advancing early detection of child maltreatment. Broader international adoption should account for policy and system-level differences and requires further validation to ensure applicability beyond the Dutch context.

来源:BMJ Paediatrics Open,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. BMJ Paediatrics Open:Enhancing implementation and compliance of the Screening Instrument for Child Abuse and Neglect (SCAN) in emergency departments in the Netherlands

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。