文献速递新生儿

新生儿科中的道德困扰:极早产儿照护中的纵向研究

Moral Distress in Neonatology.
PubMed 文献 · Pediatrics · 2021-07-20

该研究在2个三级NICU中对99名出生<28周极早产儿的照护者进行定期调查,共收集4593份问卷(应答率86%)。15%的调查场合报告道德困扰(MoD),91%的患儿在住院期间引发过MoD,主要原因为「父母要求过多」导致过度照护。新生儿科医生比护士和受训者经历更少困扰且更倾向于使照护偏好与家庭意愿一致。

要点

  • 91%的极早产儿在住院期间会引发临床医生的道德困扰(MoD)。
  • MoD与「父母要求过多」的感知强烈相关,导致过度照护。
  • 新生儿科医生比护士和受训者经历更少MoD,且更易与家庭意愿对齐照护偏好。

核心结论

  • 大多数极早产儿会引发某种程度的道德困扰,但很少被分享且持续时间不长。
  • 临床医生报告的主要限制是「父母要求过多」,导致过度照护。

研究设计与样本

  • 在2个三级NICU中,对99名出生<28周极早产儿从出生至出院或死亡的照护者进行定期调查。
  • 调查对象包括新生儿科医生、受训医生和护士,共收集4593份问卷,应答率86%。
  • 对报告显著困扰(Wocial道德困扰温度计≥6/10)的临床医生收集开放式回答,并用混合方法分析。

主要发现

  • 在18个月内,687次(15%)调查场合报告了MoD;91%的患儿在住院期间引发过MoD。
  • 开放式回答中,临床医生提及5个主要主题:婴儿相关原因(83%)、管理计划(26%)、家庭相关原因(19%)、父母决策(16%)和提供者相关原因(15%)。
  • MoD与「父母要求过多」的感知强烈相关。
  • 新生儿科医生比护士和受训者经历更少困扰,且更可能使偏好照护水平与家庭意愿一致。

临床怎么用

  • 临床团队应关注极早产儿照护中由「父母要求过多」感知引发的道德困扰,并促进团队内分享与沟通。
  • 新生儿科医生需注意护士和受训者可能经历更多道德困扰,应给予支持并促进照护偏好与家庭意愿的协调。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: To longitudinally examine the nature of moral distress (MoD) experienced by clinicians caring for extremely low gestational age neonates. METHODS: Neonatologists, medical trainees, and nurses were surveyed at regular intervals on their experience of MoD and their preferred level of care in relation to 99 neonates born <28 weeks' gestational age managed from birth until discharge or death in 2 tertiary NICUs. Clinicians reporting significant distress (≥6 of 10 on Wocial's Moral Distress Thermometer) were asked to provide open-ended responses on why they experienced MoD. Descriptive statistics were used to analyze frequency and intensity of MoD across different clinician characteristics. Open-ended responses were analyzed by using mixed methods. RESULTS: Over 18 months, 4593 of 5332 surveys (86% response rate) were collected. MoD was reported on 687 (15%) survey occasions; 91% of neonates elicited MoD during their hospitalization. In their open-ended answers, clinicians invoked 5 main themes to explain their distress: (1) infant-centered reasons (83%), including illness severity, predicted outcomes, and disproportionate care; (2) management plans (26%); (3) family-centered reasons (19%); (4) parental decision-making (16%); and (5) provider-centered reasons (15%). MoD was strongly associated with the perception of "parents wanting too much." Neonatologists experienced less distress and were more likely than nurses and trainees to align preferred levels of care with family wishes. CONCLUSIONS: The majority of preterm infants will generate some MoD; however, it is rarely shared and of a sustained nature. The main constraint reported by clinicians was "parents wanting too much," leading to disproportionate care.

来源:Pediatrics,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Prentice TM, Janvier A, Gillam L, et al. Moral Distress in Neonatology. Pediatrics. 2021. PMID: 34285081. doi:10.1542/peds.2020-031864

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。