英格兰儿科癫痫护理质量与死亡及非计划入院关联的全国纵向数据链接研究
该研究链接英格兰Epilepsy12国家临床审计两轮数据与死亡登记及住院数据,分析儿科癫痫服务单元层面绩效与患者结局的关联。研究发现,儿科神经科医生参与所有符合条件患者诊疗的单元,其患者总死亡风险及过渡后死亡风险均较低;癫痫专科护士可及性下降则与癫痫入院标化比升高相关。
要点
- 儿科神经科医生参与全部符合条件患者诊疗与总死亡风险及过渡后死亡风险降低相关。
- 癫痫专科护士或具有癫痫专长的儿科医生绩效与死亡率无显著关联。
- 癫痫专科护士可及性下降与儿科癫痫入院标化比升高相关。
核心结论
- 在青少年癫痫患者中,三级专科医生更多参与儿科护理与过渡至成人服务后全因死亡率降低相关。
- 癫痫专科护士可及性降低与儿科癫痫入院增加相关。
研究设计与样本
- 英格兰儿科癫痫服务纵向数据链接研究,链接Epilepsy12国家临床审计第1轮(2009-11)和第2轮(2013-14)的单元层面数据、英国国家统计局死亡登记及医院 Episode Statistics 非计划入院数据。
- 分析99个单元中1795例患者(儿科医生癫痫专长和癫痫专科护士分析)及55个单元中1164例患者(儿科神经科医生分析),研究期间为2009年4月1日至2015年3月31日。
主要发现
- 在99个单元中,1795例患者中134例(7%)死亡,其中88例(5%)在过渡至成人服务后死亡。
- 在55个单元中,1164例患者中79例(7%)死亡,其中54例(5%)在过渡后死亡。
临床怎么用
- 在儿科癫痫护理中应重视儿科神经科医生的参与,尤其是对符合条件患者的全面覆盖。
- 维持癫痫专科护士的可及性可能有助于减少儿科癫痫非计划入院。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Concerns have been raised about variation in care quality and outcomes among children and young people with epilepsies in England. We aimed to investigate the association between quality of paediatric care, hospital admissions, and all-cause deaths among epilepsy patients. METHODS: In this longitudinal data linkage study of paediatric epilepsy services in England, we linked unit-level data from round 1 (2009-11) and round 2 (2013-14) of the Epilepsy12 national clinical audit, with death registrations from the UK Office for National Statistics and data for unplanned hospital admissions from Hospital Episode Statistics. We investigated the association between unit-level performance in involving a paediatrician with epilepsy expertise, an epilepsy specialist nurse, and a paediatric neurologist (where appropriate) in round 1 and the proportion of adolescents (aged 10-18 years) with epilepsy admitted to each unit who subsequently died during the study period (April 1, 2009, to March 31, 2015). We also investigated whether change in Epilepsy12 performance between the two audit rounds was associated with changes in the standardised ratio of observed-to-expected unplanned epilepsy admissions over the same period. FINDINGS: In 99 units with data for the analyses relating to paediatricians with epilepsy expertise and epilepsy specialist nurses, 134 (7%) of 1795 patients died during the study period, 88 (5%) of whom died after the transition to adult service. In 55 units with data for the analyses relating to paediatric neurologists, 79 (7%) of 1164 patients died, 54 (5%) of whom did so after the transition. In regression models adjusting for population, unit, and hospital activity characteristics, absolute reductions in total mortality risk (6·4 percentage points, 95% CI 0·1-12·7) and mortality risk after transition (5·7 percentage points, 0·6-10·8) were found when comparing units where all versus no eligible patients were seen by a paediatric neurologist. Units where all eligible patients were seen by a paediatric neurologist were estimated to have absolute reductions of 4·6 percentage points (0·3-8·9) in total mortality and of 4·6 percentage points (1·2-8·0) in post-transition mortality, compared with units where no or some eligible patients were seen by a paediatric neurologist. There was no significant association between performance on being seen by an epilepsy specialist nurse or by a paediatrician with epilepsy expertise and mortality. In units where access to an epilepsy specialist nurse decreased, the standardised ratio of epilepsy admissions increased by a mean of 0·21 (0·01-0·42). INTERPRETATION: Among adolescents with epilepsy, greater involvement of tertiary specialists in paediatric care is associated with decreased all-cause mortality in the period after transition to adult services. Reduced access to an epilepsy specialist nurse was associated with an increase in paediatric epilepsy admissions. FUNDING: The Health Foundation.
引用
- Hargreaves DS, Arora S, Viveiro C, et al. Association of quality of paediatric epilepsy care with mortality and unplanned hospital admissions among children and young people with epilepsy in England: a national longitudinal data linkage study. Lancet Child Adolesc Health. 2019. PMID: 31281027. doi:10.1016/S2352-4642(19)30201-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。