美国和加拿大儿科急诊低价值诊断影像使用比较
该研究利用2006至2016年加拿大安大略省4个和美国26个儿科急诊数据库,纳入18岁及以下离院患儿,比较两国低价值影像使用。加拿大在头部CT、腹部CT、胸部X线及腹部X线的总体使用率均低于美国,多种适应症的低价值影像使用也较低,且3天和7天不良结局率相似。
要点
- 加拿大儿科急诊的头部、腹部CT及胸腹部X线使用率均显著低于美国。
- 加拿大对便秘、腹痛的腹部X线及脑震荡的头部CT等低价值影像使用率更低。
- 加拿大影像使用较低未伴随3天和7天不良结局率升高。
核心结论
- 安大略省儿科急诊的低价值影像使用率低于美国,尤其涉及电离辐射的检查,且未增加不良结局。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用2006至2016年加拿大安大略省4个和美国26个儿科急诊的管理健康数据库,纳入18岁及以下离院患儿。
主要发现
- 加拿大与美国相比,头部CT使用率为1.3% vs 3.5%,腹部CT为0.3% vs 1.0%,胸部X线为11.7% vs 15.6%,腹部X线为4.3% vs 16.5%,均P < .001。
- 加拿大低价值影像使用低于美国,如便秘腹部X线绝对差23.7%(95% CI, 23.2%-24.3%),腹痛腹部X线差20.6%(95% CI, 20.3%-21.0%),脑震荡头部CT差22.9%(95% CI, 22.3%-23.4%)。
- 便秘腹部CT使用率美国约高10倍(0.1% [95% CI, 0.1%-0.2%] vs 1.2% [95% CI, 1.2%-1.2%]),腹痛腹部CT为0.8% [95% CI, 0.7%-0.9%] vs 7.0% [95% CI, 6.9%-7.1%]。
- 加拿大与美国3天和7天急诊后不良结局率相似。
临床怎么用
- 在儿科急诊中,对便秘、腹痛、脑震荡等适应症应避免常规使用低价值影像,尤其减少电离辐射检查。
- 减少低价值影像使用未增加短期不良结局,可安全地优化影像检查决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Diagnostic imaging overuse in children evaluated in emergency departments (EDs) is a potential target for reducing low-value care. Variation in practice patterns across Canada and the United States stemming from organization of care, payment structures, and medicolegal environments may lead to differences in imaging overuse between countries. OBJECTIVE: To compare overall and low-value use of diagnostic imaging across pediatric ED visits in Ontario, Canada, and the United States. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This study used administrative health databases from 4 pediatric EDs in Ontario and 26 in the United States in calendar years 2006 through 2016. Individuals 18 years and younger who were discharged from the ED, including after visits for diagnoses in which imaging is not routinely recommended (eg, asthma, bronchiolitis, abdominal pain, constipation, concussion, febrile convulsion, seizure, and headache) were included. Data analysis occurred from April 2018 to October 2018. EXPOSURES: Diagnostic imaging use. MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURES: Overall and condition-specific low-value imaging use. Three-day and 7-day rates of hospital admission and those admissions resulting in intensive care, surgery, or in-hospital mortality were assessed as balancing measures. RESULTS: A total of 1 783 752 visits in Ontario and 21 807 332 visits in the United States were analyzed. Compared with visits in the United States, those in Canada had lower overall use of head computed tomography (Canada, 22 942 [1.3%] vs the United States, 753 270 [3.5%]; P < .001), abdomen computed tomography (5626 [0.3%] vs 211 018 [1.0%]; P < .001), chest radiographic imaging (208 843 [11.7%] vs 3 408 540 [15.6%]; P < .001), and abdominal radiographic imaging (77 147 [4.3%] vs 3 607 141 [16.5%]; P < .001). Low-value imaging use was lower in Canada than the United States for multiple indications, including abdominal radiographic images for constipation (absolute difference, 23.7% [95% CI, 23.2%-24.3%]) and abdominal pain (20.6% [95% CI, 20.3%-21.0%]) and head computed tomographic scans for concussion (22.9% [95% CI, 22.3%-23.4%]). Abdominal computed tomographic use for constipation and abdominal pain, although low overall, were approximately 10-fold higher in the United States (0.1% [95% CI, 0.1%-0.2%] vs 1.2% [95% CI, 1.2%-1.2%]) and abdominal pain (0.8% [95% CI, 0.7%-0.9%] vs 7.0% [95% CI, 6.9%-7.1%]). Rates of 3-day and 7-day post-ED adverse outcomes were similar. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Low-value imaging rates were lower in pediatric EDs in Ontario compared with the United States, particularly those involving ionizing radiation. Lower use of imaging in Canada was not associated with higher rates of adverse outcomes, suggesting that usage may be safely reduced in the United States.
引用
- Cohen E, Rodean J, Diong C, et al. Low-Value Diagnostic Imaging Use in the Pediatric Emergency Department in the United States and Canada. JAMA Pediatr. 2019. PMID: 31157877. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2019.1439
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。