评估用于常规卫生规划的幼儿早期发展测量工具
该研究系统评估中低收入国家常规服务中0-3岁儿童早期发展测量工具的准确性与可行性。共识别61种工具,对覆盖≥3个发育领域且起始年龄<2岁的27种工具进行评级,发现新近开发的群体水平工具整体评分较高,个体水平工具在可及性、培训、临床相关性和地理覆盖方面评分较低,尚无工具在所有标准上均表现优异。
要点
- 中低收入国家可用幼儿早期发展测量工具众多,但多数非多领域设计。
- 新近开发的群体水平工具在信度、文化适应性、施测时间和地理覆盖上评分较高。
- 个体水平工具在可及性、培训要求、临床相关性和地理覆盖方面普遍较差。
核心结论
- 尽管存在多种测量工具,但专为中低收入国家幼儿多领域早期发展测量设计的工具很少,且没有工具在所有准确性和可行性标准上均表现优异。
研究设计与样本
- 基于世界银行和同行评议文献综述,识别中低收入国家使用的0-3岁儿童早期发展测量工具,按儿童年龄和测量领域进行矩阵化分类。
- 对覆盖≥3个发育领域(包括认知)且起始年龄<2岁的工具,采用源自GRADE的评级方法评估准确性和可行性标准。
- 初步识别61种工具,其中8%(n=5)为群体水平,92%(n=56)为个体水平筛查或能力测试;最终对27种覆盖≥3个领域且起始年龄<2岁的工具进行评级。
主要发现
- 近期开发的群体水平工具(n=2)整体评分较高,尤其在信度、文化适应性、施测时间和地理覆盖方面。
- 个体水平工具(n=25)评分参差不齐,信度通常最高,而可及性、培训、临床相关性和地理覆盖通常最低。
关键数值与推荐
- 工具筛选标准:用于0-3岁儿童、至少在1个中低收入国家使用、覆盖≥3个发育领域(包括认知)且起始年龄<2岁。
- 评级标准包括准确性和可行性维度,如信度、文化适应性、施测时间、地理覆盖、可及性、培训要求和临床相关性。
临床怎么用
- 在常规卫生规划中选择幼儿早期发展测量工具时,需权衡多领域覆盖与可行性,尤其关注可及性、培训需求和临床相关性。
- 群体水平工具可能更适合常规监测,但需进一步验证其在中低收入国家常规服务中的适用性。
局限性
- 研究基于文献综述和评级方法,未涉及工具在实际服务中的现场验证数据。
- 仅评估了覆盖≥3个领域且起始年龄<2岁的工具,可能遗漏其他有潜力的工具。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Identification of children at risk of developmental delay and/or impairment requires valid measurement of early child development (ECD). We systematically assess ECD measurement tools for accuracy and feasibility for use in routine services in low-income and middle-income countries (LMIC). METHODS: Building on World Bank and peer-reviewed literature reviews, we identified available ECD measurement tools for children aged 0-3 years used in ≥1 LMIC and matrixed these according to when (child age) and what (ECD domains) they measure at population or individual level. Tools measuring <2 years and covering ≥3 developmental domains, including cognition, were rated for accuracy and feasibility criteria using a rating approach derived from Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations. RESULTS: 61 tools were initially identified, 8% (n=5) population-level and 92% (n=56) individual-level screening or ability tests. Of these, 27 tools covering ≥3 domains beginning <2 years of age were selected for rating accuracy and feasibility. Recently developed population-level tools (n=2) rated highly overall, particularly in reliability, cultural adaptability, administration time and geographical uptake. Individual-level tool (n=25) ratings were variable, generally highest for reliability and lowest for accessibility, training, clinical relevance and geographical uptake. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: Although multiple measurement tools exist, few are designed for multidomain ECD measurement in young children, especially in LMIC. No available tools rated strongly across all accuracy and feasibility criteria with accessibility, training requirements, clinical relevance and geographical uptake being poor for most tools. Further research is recommended to explore this gap in fit-for-purpose tools to monitor ECD in routine LMIC health services.
引用
- Boggs D, Milner KM, Chandna J, et al. Rating early child development outcome measurement tools for routine health programme use. Arch Dis Child. 2019. PMID: 30885963. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2018-315431
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。