2017年儿科医疗过度使用更新:综述
该综述通过结构化检索PubMed和手动查阅10种期刊目录,从2016年发表的169篇儿科过度使用相关文章中选出8篇高质量研究。文章按过度治疗、过度医疗化和过度诊断分类,发现商业补液盐、抗抑郁药、肠外营养等过度治疗,计划早期分娩、踝关节损伤固定、水解婴儿配方奶等过度医疗化,以及毛细支气管炎恢复期儿童低氧血症的过度诊断。相关潜在危害包括感染风险增加、发育障碍和自杀倾向。
要点
- 2016年169篇儿科过度使用文章中选出8篇高质量研究,多基于随机临床试验。
- 过度治疗涉及商业补液盐、抗抑郁药和肠外营养。
- 过度医疗化涉及计划早期分娩、踝关节损伤固定和水解婴儿配方奶。
核心结论
- 所选文章质量高,多数基于随机临床试验,儿科过度使用的潜在危害显著。
- 潜在危害包括感染风险增加、发育障碍和自杀倾向。
研究设计与样本
- 结构化检索PubMed并手动查阅10种期刊目录,识别2016年发表的169篇儿科过度使用相关文章。
- 基于方法学质量和潜在危害的患病率与程度选出8篇文章。
- 文章按过度治疗、过度医疗化和过度诊断分类。
主要发现
- 过度治疗证据涉及商业补液盐、抗抑郁药和肠外营养。
- 过度医疗化证据涉及计划早期分娩、踝关节损伤固定和水解婴儿配方奶。
- 过度诊断证据涉及毛细支气管炎恢复期儿童的低氧血症。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Medical overuse has historically focused on adult health care, but interest in how children are affected by medical overuse is increasing. This review examines important research articles published in 2016 that address pediatric overuse. OBSERVATIONS: A structured search of PubMed and a manual review of the tables of contents of 10 journals identified 169 articles related to pediatric overuse published in 2016, from which 8 were selected based on the quality of methods and potential harm to patients in terms of prevalence and magnitude. Articles were categorized by overtreatment, overmedicalization, and overdiagnosis. Findings included evidence of overtreatment with commercial rehydration solution, antidepressants, and parenteral nutrition; overmedicalization with planned early deliveries, immobilization of ankle injuries, and use of hydrolyzed infant formula; and evidence of overdiagnosis of hypoxemia among children recovering from bronchiolitis. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: The articles were of high quality, with most based on randomized clinical trials. The potential harms associated with pediatric overuse were significant, including increased risk of infection, developmental disability, and suicidality.
引用
- Coon ER, Young PC, Quinonez RA, et al. 2017 Update on Pediatric Medical Overuse: A Review. JAMA Pediatr. 2018. PMID: 29582079. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2017.5752
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。