新生儿重症监护中家长中心决策偏好的相关特征
该横断面调查纳入2016年费城3家学术附属医院NICU的136名婴儿家长,评估16项临床决策中家长对家长中心决策的偏好及7项决策特征。多因素分析显示,涉及大局目标和可能伤害婴儿的决策与家长中心决策偏好正相关,而技术性、可能受益、需医学专业知识和高紧迫性的决策与偏好负相关。
要点
- 涉及大局目标和可能伤害婴儿的决策,家长更倾向家长中心决策。
- 技术性、可能受益、需医学专业知识和高紧迫性的决策,家长更倾向医疗团队中心决策。
- 共享决策应纳入决策特征差异,允许家长在适当情形下让渡控制权。
核心结论
- NICU家长对家长中心与医疗团队中心决策的偏好可能随具体临床决策特征系统性变化。
- 将这种变异纳入共享决策并允许家长在适当临床情形下让渡控制权给医生,可能改善医疗决策质量与结局。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面调查,于2016年1月7日至7月8日在费城3家学术附属医院NICU开展,纳入136名婴儿家长。
- 评估家长对16项临床决策的家长中心与医疗团队中心决策偏好,以及7项决策特征评估。
- 对每项决策特征,多因素分析检验中、高水平(相比低水平)与家长中心决策偏好的关联,产生2个OR。
主要发现
- 家长中心决策偏好与涉及大局目标的决策正相关(中水平OR 2.01,99%CI 0.83-4.86;高水平OR 3.38,99%CI 1.48-7.75)。
- 家长中心决策偏好与可能伤害婴儿的决策正相关(中水平OR 1.32,99%CI 0.84-2.08;高水平OR 2.62,99%CI 1.67-4.11)。
- 家长中心决策偏好与技术性决策负相关(中水平OR 0.82,99%CI 0.45-1.52;高水平OR 0.48,99%CI 0.25-0.93)。
- 家长中心决策偏好与可能受益的决策负相关(中水平OR 0.42,99%CI 0.16-1.05;高水平OR 0.21,99%CI 0.08-0.52)。
- 家长中心决策偏好与需医学专业知识的决策负相关(中水平OR 0.48,99%CI 0.22-1.05;高水平OR 0.21,99%CI 0.10-0.48);与高紧迫性决策负相关(中水平OR 0.47,99%CI 0.24-0.92;高水平OR 0.42,99%CI 0.22-0.83)。
临床怎么用
- 在NICU共享决策中,可根据决策是否涉及大局目标、伤害风险、技术性、受益可能、医学专业需求及紧迫性,调整家长参与程度。
- 对于技术性强、需专业判断或高紧迫性的决策,可考虑允许家长将控制权让渡给医疗团队。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Little is known about how characteristics of particular clinical decisions influence decision-making preferences by patients or their surrogates. A better understanding of the factors underlying preferences is essential to improve the quality of shared decision making. OBJECTIVE: To identify the characteristics of particular decisions that are associated with parents' preferences for family- vs medical team-centered decision making across the spectrum of clinical decisions that arise in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cross-sectional survey assessed parents' preferences for parent- vs medical team-centered decision making across 16 clinical decisions, along with parents' assessments of 7 characteristics of those decisions. Respondents included 136 parents of infants in 1 of 3 academically affiliated hospital NICUs in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, from January 7 to July 8, 2016. Respondents represented a wide range of educational levels, employment status, and household income but were predominantly female (109 [80.1%]), white (68 [50.0%]) or African American (53 [39.0%]), and married (81 of 132 responding [61.4%]). MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Preferences for parent-centered decision making. For each decision characteristic (eg, urgency), multivariable analyses tested whether middle and high levels of that characteristic (compared with low levels) were associated with a preference for parent-centered decision making, resulting in 2 odds ratios (ORs) per decision characteristic. RESULTS: Among the 136 respondents (109 women [80.1%] and 27 men [19.9%]; median age, 30 years [range, 18-43 years]), preferences for parent-centered decision making were positively associated with decisions that involved big-picture goals (middle OR, 2.01 [99% CI, 0.83-4.86]; high OR, 3.38 [99% CI, 1.48-7.75]) and that had the potential to harm the infant (middle OR, 1.32 [99% CI, 0.84-2.08]; high OR, 2.62 [99% CI, 1.67-4.11]). In contrast, preferences for parent-centered decision making were inversely associated with the following 4 decision characteristics: technical decisions (middle OR, 0.82 [99% CI, 0.45-1.52]; high OR, 0.48 [99% CI, 0.25-0.93]), the potential to benefit the infant (middle OR, 0.42 [99% CI, 0.16-1.05]; high OR, 0.21 [99% CI, 0.08-0.52]), requires medical expertise (middle OR, 0.48 [99% CI, 0.22-1.05]; high OR, 0.21 [99% CI, 0.10-0.48]), and a high level of urgency (middle OR, 0.47 [99% CI, 0.24-0.92]; high OR, 0.42 [99% CI, 0.22-0.83]). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Preferences for parent-centered vs medical team-centered decision making among parents of infants in the NICU may vary systematically by the characteristics of particular clinical decisions. Incorporating this variation into shared decision making and endorsing models that allow parents to cede control to physicians in appropriate clinical circumstances might improve the quality and outcomes of medical decisions.
引用
- Weiss EM, Xie D, Cook N, et al. Characteristics Associated With Preferences for Parent-Centered Decision Making in Neonatal Intensive Care. JAMA Pediatr. 2018. PMID: 29554176. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2017.5776
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。