极早产儿出生时的呼吸做功比较
该回顾性研究分析了118例极早产儿出生后接受正压通气(PPV)或持续气道正压(CPAP)的复苏记录,比较生后2分钟和5分钟时的呼吸做功。结果显示,PPV组自主呼吸的分钟通气量和招募呼吸均显著低于CPAP组,但5分钟时心率和氧饱和度无差异,PPV组氧需求更高。结论认为极早产儿接受PPV时仍有自主呼吸,但呼吸做功明显降低。
要点
- 极早产儿接受PPV时仍存在自主呼吸,但呼吸做功显著低于仅接受CPAP者。
- PPV组生后2分钟和5分钟的分钟通气量及招募呼吸均低于CPAP组。
- PPV组生后2分钟心率和氧饱和度较低,5分钟时无差异,但氧需求更高。
核心结论
- 极早产儿接受PPV时仍有自主呼吸,但呼吸做功较仅接受CPAP者显著降低,这可能是多数患儿应用PPV的合理依据。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析118例极早产儿出生后接受PPV或CPAP的复苏记录,其中PPV组87例,CPAP组31例。
主要发现
- PPV组生后2分钟分钟通气量为37 mL/kg/min(IQR 15-69),CPAP组为188 mL/kg/min(IQR 128-297),P < .001。
- PPV组生后5分钟分钟通气量为112 mL/kg/min(IQR 46-229),CPAP组为205 mL/kg/min(IQR 174-327),P < .001。
- PPV组生后2分钟招募呼吸为0次/分钟(IQR 0-1),CPAP组为4次/分钟(IQR 1-8),P < .001;5分钟时分别为0次/分钟(IQR 0-3)和2次/分钟(IQR 0-11),P = .01。
- PPV组生后2分钟心率较低(94次/分钟 [IQR 68-128] vs 124次/分钟 [IQR 100-144],P = .02),氧饱和度较低(50% [IQR 35%-66%] vs 67% [IQR 34%-80%],P = .04),5分钟时两者无显著差异。
- PPV组氧需求更高:2分钟时为30%(IQR 21%-53%)vs 21%(IQR 21%-29%),P = .05;5分钟时为39%(IQR 22%-91%)vs 22%(IQR 21%-31%),P = .003。
临床怎么用
- 对于极早产儿出生时接受PPV者,应认识到其自主呼吸做功可能较低,需密切评估呼吸状态。
- PPV组氧需求较高,临床中需注意氧浓度调整,避免不必要的氧暴露。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性分析,样本量有限,PPV组与CPAP组胎龄和出生体重存在差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the respiratory effort of very preterm infants receiving positive pressure ventilation (PPV) with infants breathing on continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP), directly after birth. STUDY DESIGN: Recorded resuscitations of very preterm infants receiving PPV or CPAP after birth were analyzed retrospectively. The respiratory effort (minute volume and recruitment breaths [>8 mL/kg], heart rate, oxygen saturation, and oxygen requirement were analyzed for the first 2 minutes and in the fifth minute after birth. RESULTS: Respiratory effort was analyzed in 118 infants, 87 infants receiving PPV and 31 infants receiving CPAP (median gestational age, 28 weeks [IQR, 26-29] vs 29 weeks [IQR, 29-30; P < .001); birth weight, 1059 g [IQR, 795-1300] vs 1205 g [IQR, 956-1418; P = .06]). The minute volume of spontaneous breaths of infants receiving PPV was lower at 2 minutes (37 mL/kg/minute [IQR, 15-69] vs 188 mL/kg/minute [IQR, 128-297; P < .001]) and at 5 minutes (112 mL/kg/minute [IQR, 46-229] vs 205 mL/kg/minute [IQR, 174-327; P < .001]). Recruitment breaths occurred less in the PPV group at 2 minutes (0 breaths/minute [IQR, 0-1] vs 4 breaths/minute [IQR, 1-8; P < .001]) and 5 minutes (0 breaths/minute [IQR, 0-3] vs 2 breaths/minute [IQR, 0-11; P = .01). The heart rate was lower in the PPV group (94 beats/minute [IQR, 68-128] vs 124 beats/minute [IQR, 100-144; P = .02]) as was oxygen saturation (50% [IQR, 35%-66%] vs 67% [IQR, 34%-80%; P = .04]), but not different at 5 minutes (heart rate, 149 beats/minute [IQR, 131-162] vs 150 beats/minute [IQR, 132-160; P = NS]; oxygen saturation , 91% [IQR, 80%-95%] vs 92% [IQR, 89%-97%; P = NS]). The oxygen requirement was higher (at 2 minutes, 30% [IQR, 21%-53%] vs 21% [IQR, 21%-29%; P = .05]; at 5 minutes, 39% [IQR, 22%-91%] vs 22% [IQR, 21%-31%; P = .003]). CONCLUSION: Very preterm infants breathe at birth when receiving PPV, but the respiratory effort was significantly lower when compared with infants receiving CPAP only. The reduced breathing effort observed likely justified applying PPV in most infants.
引用
- Huberts TJP, Foglia EE, Narayen IC, et al. The Breathing Effort of Very Preterm Infants at Birth. J Pediatr. 2018. PMID: 29336795. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2017.11.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。