马来西亚儿童人体测量状况评估中不同国际参考标准的比较
该研究基于马来西亚6414名6-18岁儿童数据,比较WHO 2007、IOTF 2012和CDC 2000三种BMI参考标准对儿童消瘦、超重和肥胖分类的一致性及患病率估计的影响。结果显示消瘦分类一致性差至中等,超重和肥胖分类一致性总体较好,但三种参考标准得出的患病率估计明显不一致,提示参考标准选择可能影响临床管理和公共卫生干预策略。
要点
- 三种国际BMI参考标准对儿童消瘦分类的一致性差至中等,对超重和肥胖分类一致性总体较好。
- WHO参考标准估计的超重和肥胖患病率高于其他两种参考标准。
- IOTF参考标准估计的消瘦患病率最多高8.5%,肥胖患病率约低4%。
核心结论
- 表达BMI所选用的参考标准可能影响对儿童人体测量状况和营养不良患病率的结论,进而影响临床管理和公共卫生干预策略。
研究设计与样本
- 研究评估了东南亚社区观测站收集的6414名6-18岁儿童数据,按WHO 2007、IOTF 2012和CDC 2000三种国际BMI参考标准分类消瘦、超重和肥胖,并用Cohen kappa统计量评估分类一致性,用混合效应泊松回归估计各参考标准下的患病率。
主要发现
- 三种参考标准在消瘦分类上一致性差至中等,在超重和肥胖分类上一致性总体较好。
- 三种参考标准生成的消瘦、超重和肥胖患病率估计明显不一致。
- WHO参考标准估计的超重和肥胖患病率高于其他两种参考标准。
- 使用IOTF参考标准时,消瘦患病率最多高8.5%,肥胖患病率约低4%。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估儿童人体测量状况时需注意所用BMI参考标准,不同标准可能得出不同的营养不良患病率结论。
- 在临床管理和公共卫生干预中应明确说明所采用的参考标准,以避免因标准不同导致的分类差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess the prevalence of child underweight, overweight, and obesity in a Malaysian population according to 3 international references because classification of anthropometric status may differ according to the reference used to express body mass index (BMI). STUDY DESIGN: We assessed data from 6414 children aged 6-18 years, collected by the South East Asia Community Observatory. Child underweight, overweight, and obesity were expressed according to 3 internationally used BMI references: World Health Organization 2007, International Obesity Task Force 2012, and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2000. We assessed agreement in classification of anthropometric status among the references using Cohen's kappa statistic and estimated underweight, overweight, and obesity prevalence according to each reference using mixed effects Poisson regression. RESULTS: There was poor to moderate agreement between references when classifying underweight, but generally good agreement when classifying overweight and obesity. Underweight, overweight, and obesity prevalence estimates generated using the 3 references were notably inconsistent. Overweight and obesity prevalence estimates were higher using the World Health Organization reference vs the other 2, and underweight prevalence was up to 8.5% higher and obesity prevalence was about 4% lower when using the International Obesity Task Force reference. CONCLUSIONS: The choice of reference to express BMI may influence conclusions about child anthropometric status and malnutrition prevalence. This has implications regarding strategies for clinical management and public health interventions.
引用
- Partap U, Young EH, Allotey P, et al. The Use of Different International References to Assess Child Anthropometric Status in a Malaysian Population. J Pediatr. 2017. PMID: 29144273. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2017.07.049
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。