儿童结核性胸膜炎诊断要点的探索性研究
该回顾性研究纳入113例结核性胸膜炎患儿与113例5岁以上支原体肺炎合并胸腔积液患儿对照,分析发热、咳嗽、肺内病灶、胸腔积液单双侧、胸腔积液ADA及PPD试验对诊断的价值。结果显示无咳嗽、肺内无病灶、PPD阳性各自特异度高,单侧胸腔积液敏感度高但特异度低,联合上述指标可提高特异度。
要点
- 5岁以上持续发热伴胸腔积液患儿,即使无咳嗽或肺内无病灶也应考虑结核性胸膜炎。
- 无咳嗽、肺内无病灶、PPD阳性三项各自对诊断结核性胸膜炎特异度高。
- 单侧胸腔积液敏感度高但特异度仅28.3%,需联合其他指标提高特异度。
核心结论
- 对于5岁以上以发热、胸腔积液为主要表现,缺乏咳嗽症状、肺内无病灶(压缩性肺不张除外)或PPD阳性三项均可单独作为诊断结核性胸膜炎的特征性指标。
- 单侧胸腔积液分别联合上述三项指标有利于提高诊断特异度。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入首都医科大学附属北京儿童医院呼吸二科2006年8月至2014年9月确诊的113例结核性胸膜炎患儿。
- 对照组为同期住院的5岁以上支原体肺炎合并胸腔积液患儿随机抽取113例。
- 分析发热、咳嗽、肺内病灶、胸腔积液单双侧、胸腔积液腺苷脱氨酶水平及PPD试验,并计算各单项及联合指标的敏感度和特异度。
主要发现
- 结核性胸膜炎组与支原体肺炎合并胸腔积液组持续发热比例分别为92.0%(104例)和98.2%(111例)。
- 两组咳嗽比例分别为47.8%(54例)和99.1%(112例)(χ²=76.3,P<0.01)。
- 两组除压缩性肺不张外肺内明确病灶比例分别为22.1%(25例)和100.0%(113例)(χ²=144.1,P<0.01)。
- 两组单侧胸腔积液比例分别为94.7%(107例)和71.7%(81例)(χ²=21.4,P<0.01)。
- 两组胸腔积液腺苷脱氨酶水平分别为46.4(22.0~70.9)U/L和39.5(26.3~78.5)U/L;PPD试验阳性比例分别为93.8%(106例)和3.5%(4例)(χ²=184.3,P<0.01)。
关键数值与推荐
- 无咳嗽症状诊断结核性胸膜炎的敏感度为52.2%,特异度为99.1%。
- 肺内无病灶诊断结核性胸膜炎的敏感度为77.9%,特异度为100.0%。
- 单侧胸腔积液诊断结核性胸膜炎的敏感度为94.7%,特异度为28.3%。
- PPD试验阳性诊断结核性胸膜炎的敏感度为93.8%,特异度为96.5%。
- 单侧胸腔积液联合PPD阳性、联合无咳嗽、联合肺内无病灶的敏感度分别为88.5%、50.4%、73.5%,特异度分别为96.5%、99.1%、100.0%。
临床怎么用
- 对5岁以上持续发热伴胸腔积液的患儿,应警惕结核性胸膜炎,即使缺乏咳嗽或肺内无病灶。
- PPD试验阳性可作为支持结核性胸膜炎诊断的特异性指标。
- 单侧胸腔积液不宜单独用于诊断,需联合PPD阳性、无咳嗽或肺内无病灶以提高特异度、减少误诊。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To summarize the clinical diagnostic essentials of pediatric tuberculous pleurisy so as to reduce the misdiagnosis rate. Method: A retrospective study was conducted on 113 cases of tuberculous pleurisy who were seen from August 2006 to September 2014 in the second Department of Respiratory Medicine, Beijing Children's Hospital Affiliated to Capital Medical University. Meanwhile, another 113 cases of children over 5 years of age with mycoplasma pneumoniae pneumonia complicated with pleural effusion were randomly selected as control group. The following five items were analyzed in relation to the diagnosis: fever, cough, lung lesions, pleural effusion(unilateral or bilateral), adenosine deaminase (ADA) level in pleural effusion, tuberculin skin test(PPD). The sensitivity and specificity of single item and combined items in diagnosis were studied. Result: (1) Among two groups, the proportion of patients with persisting fever was 92.0% (104 cases) and 98.2% (111 cases), while the proportion of patients with cough was 47.8% (54 cases) and 99.1% (112 cases) (χ(2)=76.3, P<0.01), respectively. There were 25(22.1%) cases and 113(100.0%) cases with lung lesions (except for atelectasis) in two groups (χ(2)=144.1, P<0.01), respectively. The proportion of patients with unilateral pleural effusion was 94.7%(107 cases) and 71.7%(81 cases)(χ(2)=21.4, P<0.01) while the patients with positive PPD results was 93.8%(106 cases) and 3.5%(4 cases)(χ(2)=184.3, P<0.01). The level of ADA in pleural effusion in both groups are comparable[46.4(22.0-70.9)U/L]and[39.5(26.3-78.5)U/L]. (2)The sensitivity of the lack of cough, lack of lung lesions, unilateral pleural effusion and PPD test positive in diagnosis of tuberculous pleurisy were 52.2%, 77.9%, 94.7%, 93.8%, while the specificity was 99.1%, 100.0%, 28.3%, 96.5%, respectively. Among the four items, the specificity of unilateral pleural effusion was only 28.3%, so it needed to be added with other indicators to improve the specificity. The sensitivity of unilateral pleural effusion combined with positive PPD, lack of cough, lack of lung lesions were 88.5%, 50.4% and 73.5%, while the specificity was 96.5%, 99.1%, and 100.0%, respectively, which significantly improved the specificity so as to reduce misdiagnosis. Conclusion: In children aged over 5 years who present with persistent fever and pleural effusion, tuberculous pleurisy should be considered even in the absence of cough or lung lesions(except for atelectasis), or with positive PPD result, any of the three features is specific for the diagnosis. Unilateral pleural effusion is more meaningful for the diagnosis when it is combined with any of the above three features. 目的: 分析儿童结核性胸膜炎的临床诊断要点,降低误诊率。 方法: 回顾性分析首都医科大学附属北京儿童医院呼吸二科2006年8月至2014年9月确诊的113例结核性胸膜炎患儿的临床资料,并对同期住院的5岁以上支原体肺炎合并胸腔积液患儿随机抽取113例作为对照组,分析与诊断密切相关的临床特点:发热、咳嗽、肺内病灶、胸腔积液(单侧或双侧)、胸腔积液腺苷脱氨酶水平、结核菌纯蛋白衍生物(PPD)皮肤试验,并分析各单项指标、联合指标在诊断结核性胸膜炎的敏感度和特异度。 结果: (1)结核性胸膜炎组和支原体肺炎合并胸腔积液组持续发热患儿分别为104例(92.0%)、111例(98.2%),伴有咳嗽症状的患儿分别为54例(47.8%)、112例(99.1%)(χ(2)=76.3,P<0.01),除压缩性肺不张外肺内有明确病灶的患儿分别为25例(22.1%)、113例(100.0%)(χ(2)=144.1,P<0.01),单侧胸腔积液的患儿分别为107例(94.7%)、81例(71.7%)(χ(2)=21.4,P<0.01),胸腔积液腺苷脱氨酶水平分别为46.4(22.0~70.9)U/L、39.5(26.3~78.5)U/L,PPD试验阳性患儿分别为106例(93.8%)、4例(3.5%)(χ(2)=184.3,P<0.01)。(2)应用无咳嗽症状、肺内无病灶、单侧胸腔积液、PPD试验阳性等4项指标诊断结核性胸膜炎的敏感度分别为52.2%、77.9%、94.7%、93.8%,特异度分别为99.1%、100.0%、28.3%、96.5%,4项指标中单侧胸腔积液的特异度低,故需加入其他指标以提高特异度,单侧胸腔积液联合PPD阳性,单侧胸腔积液联合无咳嗽症状,单侧胸腔积液联合肺内无病灶的敏感度分别为88.5%、50.4%、73.5%,特异度分别为96.5%、99.1%、100.0%。 结论: 对于5岁以上,以发热、胸腔积液为主要表现,缺乏咳嗽症状,肺内无病灶(压缩性肺不张除外),PPD阳性3项均可单独作为诊断结核性胸膜炎特征性的指标,单侧胸腔积液分别联合上述3项指标有利于提高诊断特异度。.
引用
- Xu H, Liu JR, Zhao SY, et al. [Exploratory research on diagnostic essentials of pediatric tuberculous pleurisy]. Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi. 2017. PMID: 28728264. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0578-1310.2017.07.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。