文献速递新生儿儿童神经与发育行为

儿科提供者对新生儿及其他脆弱患者复苏决策的观点

Provider Perspectives Regarding Resuscitation Decisions for Neonates and Other Vulnerable Patients.
PubMed 文献 · J Pediatr · 2017-05-11

该研究通过结构化调查和访谈,评估儿科住院医师和新生儿护士对6名不同年龄危重患者复苏决策的看法。结果显示,参与者决策时考虑患者特征(96%)、个人经验/偏见(85%)、家庭意愿(81%)等因素,其中85%对新生儿有负面偏见,60%不阅读、误解或不信任新生儿结局统计数据;讨论这些先入之见后,70%表示会改变答案以支持新生儿。

要点

  • 85%参与者对新生儿有负面偏见,60%不阅读、误解或不信任新生儿结局统计。
  • 决策因素包括患者特征(96%)、个人经验/偏见(85%)、家庭意愿(81%)等。
  • 讨论先入之见后,70%参与者表示会改变答案以支持新生儿。

核心结论

  • 新生儿复苏决策基于许多因素,如人格考虑和家庭利益(非传统获益指标),这可能解释新生儿决策的不同。

主要发现

  • 决策时考虑患者特征(96%)、个人经验/偏见(85%)、家庭意愿(81%)、疾病特征(74%)、社会观点(36%)。
  • 85%报告对新生儿有负面偏见,60%不阅读、误解和/或不信任新生儿结局统计。
  • 为新生儿舒适护理辩护的因素包括有限的人格和缺乏关系/依恋(73%)、优先家庭最佳利益和社会可接受死亡(36%)。
  • 讨论先入之见后,70%受访者表示会改变答案以支持新生儿。

临床怎么用

  • 临床决策中应意识到对新生儿的负面偏见和个人经验的影响。
  • 促进对新生儿结局统计的正确理解和信任。
  • 通过讨论先入之见,可能改变决策以更支持新生儿。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To use structured surveys to assess the perspectives of pediatric residents and neonatal nurses on resuscitation decisions for vulnerable patients, including neonates. STUDY DESIGN: Pediatric providers were surveyed using scenarios for 6 critically ill patients of different ages with outcomes explicitly described. Providers were asked (1) whether resuscitation was in each patient's best interest; (2) whether they would accept families' wishes for comfort care (no resuscitation); and (3) to rank patients in order of priority for resuscitation. In a structured interview, each participant explained how they evaluated patient interests and when applicable, why their answers differed for neonates. Interviews were audiotaped; transcripts were analyzed using thematic analysis and mixed methods. RESULTS: Eighty pediatric residents and neonatal nurses participated (response rate 74%). When making life and death decisions, participants considered (1) patient characteristics (96%), (2) personal experience/biases (85%), (3) family's wishes and desires (81%), (4) disease characteristics (74%), and (5) societal perspectives (36%). These factors were not in favor of sick neonates: of the participants, 85% reported having negative biases toward neonates and 60% did not read, misinterpreted, and/or distrusted neonatal outcome statistics. Additional factors used to justify comfort care for neonates included limited personhood and lack of relationships/attachment (73%); prioritization of family's best interest, and social acceptability of death (36%). When these preconceptions were discussed, 70% of respondents reported they would change their answers in favor of neonates. CONCLUSIONS: Resuscitation decisions for neonates are based on many factors, such as considerations of personhood and family's interests (that are not traditional indicators of benefit), which may explain why decision making is different for the neonatal population.

来源:J Pediatr,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Dupont-Thibodeau A, Hindié J, Bourque CJ, et al. Provider Perspectives Regarding Resuscitation Decisions for Neonates and Other Vulnerable Patients. J Pediatr. 2017. PMID: 28502606. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2017.03.057

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。