家长上传患病儿童视频作为医学信息来源的质量分析
该研究检索YouTube上家长上传的儿童哮吼和脱水视频,用医学视频评定量表分析质量。38个哮吼视频中15个为良好临床示例,仅7个同时技术质量高;28个脱水视频中2个为良好临床示例,仅1个技术质量高。结论认为此类视频难以筛选,家长可能被误导。
要点
- 家长上传的儿童疾病视频中同时具备良好临床示例和高技术质量者极少。
- 哮吼视频中良好临床示例比例高于脱水视频。
- 医护人员应谨慎讨论YouTube医学信息并考虑建立优质资源库。
核心结论
- 家长上传的儿童疾病视频中,同时显示良好临床示例和高技术质量的视频非常少。
- 从海量信息中筛选此类示例极其困难且耗时,家长可能被表面技术质量高但临床示例不佳的视频误导。
研究设计与样本
- 研究检索YouTube使用「croup+child」和「dehydration+child」两个搜索词,各筛选前400个视频。
- 排除医生或教育机构创建的视频,对家长上传视频使用经过验证的医学视频评定量表分析,并分别评估是否为良好临床示例。
主要发现
- 38个符合标准的哮吼视频中,15个被判断为良好临床示例,其中仅7个同时技术质量高。
- 28个符合纳入标准的脱水视频中,2个为良好临床示例,其中1个技术质量高。
临床怎么用
- 医护人员与家长讨论在YouTube上查找医学信息时应保持谨慎。
- 可考虑创建良好示例的资源库,以便引导家长获取更可靠的资源。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: YouTube is a vast source of freely accessible user-uploaded medical information. To our knowledge no study has analysed the quality of parent-uploaded videos which depict illness in their children. We aimed to investigate the quality and quantity of videos representing two common conditions, croup and dehydration. METHOD: YouTube was searched using the search terms 'croup+child' and 'dehydration+child'. The first 400 videos of each search were screened. Videos created by doctors or by educational institutions were excluded. The parent-uploaded videos were analysed using the validated Medical Video Rating Scale. Each video was separately evaluated for whether it represented a good clinical example of the condition featured. RESULTS: Out of 38 'croup' videos which met criteria, 15 were judged to be good clinical examples. Only 7 of these 15 'good clinical example' videos were also of high technical quality. Out of 28 'dehydration' videos which met the inclusion criteria, two were good clinical examples. One of these videos had good technical quality. CONCLUSIONS: There were very few videos of either condition which showed a good clinical example while also displaying high technical quality. It is extremely difficult and time consuming to isolate such examples from the mass of information available and therefore parents could be misled by apparently high technical quality videos which are not in fact good clinical examples. Healthcare professionals should be careful when discussing finding medical information on YouTube and consider creating repositories of good examples so they are able to direct parents towards more reputable resources.
引用
- Knight K, van Leeuwen DM, Roland D, et al. YouTube: are parent-uploaded videos of their unwell children a useful source of medical information for other parents? Arch Dis Child. 2017. PMID: 28104624. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2016-311967
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。