文献速递儿童呼吸儿童感染

儿童过度医疗更新:2015年文献综述

Update on Pediatric Overuse.
PubMed 文献 · Pediatrics · 2017-01-03

该综述通过结构化PubMed检索和手动目录回顾,识别2015年发表的儿童过度医疗重要文献,按方法学质量、临床效应大小和潜在受影响患者数评估,分为过度诊断、过度治疗和过度利用三类。研究发现毛细支气管炎低氧血症和轻微头部外伤颅骨骨折存在过度诊断证据,影像学肺炎患儿中高达85%可能无细菌病因,骨髓炎长疗程静脉抗生素与口服疗效相当,青少年抗抑郁药和雾化高渗盐水治疗毛细支气管炎无效,高胆红素血症治疗阈值可能过低。

要点

  • 毛细支气管炎低氧血症和轻微头部外伤颅骨骨折存在过度诊断证据。
  • 影像学肺炎住院患儿中高达85%可能无细菌病因,骨髓炎口服治疗与静脉疗效相当。
  • 青少年抗抑郁药和雾化高渗盐水治疗毛细支气管炎无效,高胆红素血症治疗阈值可能过低。

核心结论

  • 儿童同样受到过度医疗的危害,需要识别和对抗儿童过度医疗。

研究设计与样本

  • 通过结构化PubMed检索和手动目录回顾,识别2015年发表的儿童过度医疗重要文献,按方法学质量、临床效应大小和潜在受影响患者数评估。

主要发现

  • 过度诊断方面,有证据显示毛细支气管炎患儿低氧血症和轻微头部外伤患儿颅骨骨折存在过度诊断。
  • 过度治疗方面,有证据显示高达85%的影像学肺炎住院患儿可能无细菌病因。
  • 过度治疗方面,许多骨髓炎患儿接受长疗程静脉抗生素治疗,而口服治疗同等有效。
  • 过度治疗方面,青少年抗抑郁药和雾化高渗盐水治疗毛细支气管炎似乎无效。
  • 过度治疗方面,高胆红素血症治疗阈值可能过低。

临床怎么用

  • 临床应警惕毛细支气管炎低氧血症和轻微头部外伤颅骨骨折的过度诊断。
  • 影像学肺炎住院患儿中高达85%可能无细菌病因,应审慎评估抗生素使用。
  • 骨髓炎可考虑口服治疗替代长疗程静脉抗生素,青少年抗抑郁药和雾化高渗盐水治疗毛细支气管炎无效。
  • 高胆红素血症治疗阈值可能过低,头围筛查频率可放宽,阑尾炎腹部CT大幅减少安全有效,新生儿早发败血症不应过度依赖CRP。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

As concerns over health care-related harms and costs continue to mount, efforts to identify and combat medical overuse are needed. Although much of the recent attention has focused on health care for adults, children are also harmed by overuse. Using a structured PubMed search and manual tables of contents review, we identified important articles on pediatric overuse published in 2015. These articles were evaluated according to the quality of the methods, the magnitude of clinical effect, and the number of patients potentially affected and were categorized into overdiagnosis, overtreatment, and overutilization. Overdiagnosis: Findings included evidence for overdiagnosis of hypoxemia in children with bronchiolitis and skull fractures in children suffering minor head injuries. Overtreatment: Findings included evidence that up to 85% of hospitalized children with radiographic pneumonia may not have a bacterial etiology; many children are receiving prolonged intravenous antibiotic therapy for osteomyelitis although oral therapy is equally effective; antidepressant medication for adolescents and nebulized hypertonic saline for bronchiolitis appear to be ineffective; and thresholds for treatment of hyperbilirubinemia may be too low. Overutilization: Findings suggested that the frequency of head circumference screening could be relaxed; large reductions in abdominal computed tomography testing for appendicitis appear to have been safe and effective; and overreliance on C-reactive protein levels in neonatal early onset sepsis appears to extend hospital length-of-stay.

来源:Pediatrics,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Coon ER, Young PC, Quinonez RA, et al. Update on Pediatric Overuse. Pediatrics. 2017. PMID: 28049113. doi:10.1542/peds.2016-2797

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。