指南与共识儿童呼吸

儿童急诊哮喘指南推荐评分的地域差异与验证现状

Analysis of the asthma scores recommended in guidelines for children presenting to the emergency department: a Pediatric Emergency Research Networks study.
指南 / 共识 · Arch Dis Child · 2025-05-16

本研究分析了全球儿科急诊研究网络(PERN)中158部儿童急性哮喘管理指南,发现53%(83/158)推荐床旁临床评分评估哮喘严重度。推荐情况存在显著地域差异:西班牙和加拿大指南均推荐单一国家特异性评分,美国96%(27/28)指南推荐多种评分,而英国、爱尔兰、澳大利亚、新西兰及其他国家指南很少推荐评分。PRAM和PS是最常用评分,PRAM验证最广泛,PS验证有限。

要点

  • 53%的儿童哮喘指南推荐床旁临床评分,但推荐率与评分类型存在显著地域差异。
  • PRAM和PS是最常用评分,PRAM验证最广泛,PS验证研究有限。
  • 许多评分在评分者间信度、效标效度、反应度和区分效度方面存在不足。

核心结论

  • 儿童哮喘指南对临床评分的推荐及评分类型存在明显地域差异,多数推荐评分验证不足。

研究设计与样本

  • 观察性研究,分析来自儿科急诊研究网络(PERN)各机构儿童急性哮喘管理指南中推荐的哮喘评分,共识别158部指南。

主要发现

  • 83/158(53%)指南推荐床旁临床评分用于评估哮喘严重度。
  • 西班牙和加拿大所有指南均推荐单一国家特异性临床评分。
  • 美国27/28(96%)指南推荐多种评分,而PERUKI、PREDICT及其他国家指南很少推荐评分。
  • PRAM和PS是最常用评分工具,PRAM验证最广泛,PS验证研究有限。
  • 许多评分常见局限包括评分者间信度、效标效度、反应度和区分效度方面的问题。

关键数值与推荐

  • 158部指南中83部(53%)推荐床旁临床评分。
  • 美国指南中27/28(96%)推荐多种评分。
  • 西班牙和加拿大指南均推荐单一国家特异性评分。

临床怎么用

  • 临床实践中选用儿童哮喘评分时需注意地域指南差异及评分验证程度。
  • 优先选择验证较充分的评分如PRAM,对验证有限的评分如PS应谨慎解读。

局限性

  • 原文未报告研究局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

RATIONALE: While there are numerous published paediatric asthma scores, it is unknown how commonly scores are recommended in asthma guidelines across different geographical regions globally, and what their validation status is. OBJECTIVES: (1) To describe which clinical guidelines recommend asthma scores across different geographical regions. (2) To describe the initial and subsequent validation of the commonly recommended asthma scores. METHODS: Observational study of asthma scores recommended in guidelines for the management of acute paediatric asthma from institutions across the Pediatric Emergency Medicine Network; global paediatric emergency medicine research network comprising all eight local and regional paediatric emergency medicine research networks. MAIN RESULTS: 158 guidelines were identified. Overall, 83/158 (53%) guidelines recommend a bedside clinical score for assessment of asthma severity. While a single country-specific clinical score was recommended in all guidelines from Spain and Canada, 27/28 (96%) of the USA guidelines recommend a wide variety of scores, and scores are rarely recommended in guidelines from other research networks (PERUKI, Paediatric Emergency Research in the UK and Ireland and PREDICT, Paediatric Research in Emergency Departments International Collaborative in Australia and New Zealand) and other countries (Costa Rica, South Africa, Nigeria, Singapore, India).The Pediatric Respiratory Assessment Measure (PRAM) and the pulmonary score (PS) were the most frequently used scoring instruments. While the PRAM has undergone the most extensive validation, including construct validity, validation studies for the PS are limited. Inter-rater reliability, as well as the criterion, responsiveness and discriminative validity aspects represent the most common limitations in many of the scores. CONCLUSIONS: There are marked geographical differences in both the recommendation for and the type of clinical asthma score in clinical practice guidelines. While many asthma scores are recommended, most have insufficient validation.

来源:Arch Dis Child,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gray C, Collings M, Benito J, et al. Analysis of the asthma scores recommended in guidelines for children presenting to the emergency department: a Pediatric Emergency Research Networks study. Arch Dis Child. 2025. PMID: 40155002. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2024-327635

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。