儿童与青少年近乎致命性哮喘:一项国际eDelphi研究
该研究通过文献、指南与多媒体综述结合三轮国际eDelphi,由25国104名参与者对儿童与青少年最严重哮喘发作的命名和定义达成共识。结果显示「近乎致命性哮喘(NFA)」为首选名称(66.7%),22个条目纳入主干定义并获79.8%同意。
要点
- 儿童与青少年最严重哮喘发作的共识名称为「近乎致命性哮喘(NFA)」。
- 定义由22个共识条目组成主干文本,最终获83/104(79.8%)参与者同意。
- 共识流程采用1–5分Likert评分,≥70%的4分与5分合计视为达成共识。
核心结论
- 该研究为儿童与青少年近乎致命性哮喘提供了首选名称和共识定义。
研究设计与样本
- 通过范围综述、国际指南与多媒体轶事证据综述形成条目,开展三轮国际eDelphi。
- 参与者为来自25个国家的儿科与成人呼吸、急诊或重症监护的急性哮喘诊疗顾问。
- 104名参与者完成全部三轮,最终轮提供主干定义及两个附加选项。
主要发现
- 第二轮参与者额外提供10个条目和3个名称。
- 第三轮中近乎致命性哮喘(NFA)以66.7%成为首选名称。
- 第二轮达成共识的22个条目被置于主干文本,定义获83/104(79.8%)同意。
关键数值与推荐
- Likert评分1–5分,4分与5分合计≥70%视为达成共识。
- 近乎致命性哮喘(NFA)在第三轮以66.7%成为首选名称。
- 22个条目达成第二轮共识并纳入主干定义文本。
- 最终定义获83/104(79.8%)参与者同意。
临床怎么用
- 可采用NFA作为儿童与青少年最严重哮喘发作的统一名称与共识定义。
- 该共识有助于更好地刻画并照护这一脆弱人群。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Guidelines and evidence identify that children and young people (CYP) who die from asthma frequently have a severe preceding attack. There is no agreed name or case definition for the most severe form of asthma attack. We aimed to resolve this using a structured literature, guideline and multimedia review to inform an international electronic Delphi (eDelphi) process. METHODS: A scoping literature, international guideline and anecdotal evidence (multimedia reporting) review provided items and potential names for round 1 of 3 for an eDelphi. Likert scoring of 1-5, with ≥70% combined score of 4 and 5 provided consensus. Free text enabled additional items and names to be offered. Participants were consultants providing acute asthma care in paediatric and adult respiratory, emergency or critical care medicine from 25 countries. In the final round, participants were provided with a stem definition with two further add-on options. RESULTS: Fifty-two studies were identified by scoping review (from 586 studies) with 27 international guidelines providing 41 items and 4 potential names to round 1. 104 participants completed all 3 rounds, offering an additional 10 items and 3 names for round 2. Near-fatal asthma (NFA) was the preferred name in round 3 (66.7%). The 22 items reaching round 2 consensus were placed within stem text where a definition was agreed (83/104, 79.8%). CONCLUSIONS: This study provides a preferred name and consensus definition of NFA in CYP. This research can enable better characterisation and delivery of care to this vulnerable population.
引用
- McMurray A, Fleming L, Cunningham S, et al. Near-fatal asthma in children and young adults: an international eDelphi Study. Arch Dis Child. 2025. PMID: 40049753. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2024-327888
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。