指南与共识

美国儿科学会指南中证据质量与推荐强度的分析

Quality of Evidence and Strength of Recommendations in American Academy of Pediatrics' Guidelines.
指南 / 共识 · Pediatrics · 2025-01-01

该研究系统梳理了美国儿科学会(AAP)当前14部临床实践指南,由3名独立评审员提取每条推荐的证据质量与推荐强度。共236条推荐中,仅10.6%基于A级证据,34.7%为强推荐,且部分强推荐基于X级证据或C级证据。结论认为需更多研究提升儿科指南证据质量。

要点

  • AAP指南中仅10.6%推荐基于A级证据,近半数(47.5%)基于B级证据。
  • 强推荐占34.7%,其中13%基于X级证据;中等推荐占49.6%,其中42.7%基于C级证据。
  • 14部指南共236条推荐,每部指南推荐数1至39条(均值16.9,中位数15)。

核心结论

  • AAP当前临床实践指南中仅少数推荐(10.6%)基于最高质量证据,需更多研究改善儿科指南证据基础。

研究设计与样本

  • 从AAP官网识别当前14部临床实践指南,由3名独立评审员提取每条推荐的证据质量与推荐强度,分歧经共识解决,采用描述性统计分析。

主要发现

  • 14部指南共236条推荐,每部指南推荐数1至39条(均值16.9,中位数15)。

关键数值与推荐

  • A级证据:设计实施良好的试验或荟萃分析;B级:有轻微局限的试验或多项观察性研究结果一致;C级:单项或少数观察性研究,或结果不一致/有重大局限的多项研究;D级:专家意见、病例报告或基于基本原理的推理;X级:无法进行验证性研究但获益或危害明显占优的特殊情况。

临床怎么用

  • 临床参考AAP指南时应关注推荐背后的证据等级与推荐强度,对基于C级或X级证据的强推荐保持审慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Summarize the quality of the evidence and the strength of recommendations in the American Academy of Pediatrics' (AAP) current clinical practice guidelines. METHODS: We identified the AAP's current clinical practice guidelines from its website. Three independent reviewers abstracted each recommendation, the quality of evidence supporting it, and its strength from every guideline. We resolved discrepancies by consensus and analyzed results using descriptive statistics. RESULTS: We identified 14 current clinical practice guidelines. Individual guidelines make between 1 and 39 recommendations (mean 16.9, median 15), and the guidelines make a total of 236 recommendations. Twenty-five (10.6%) recommendations are based on Level A evidence (well-designed and -conducted trials, meta-analyses), 112 (47.5%) Level B (trials with minor limitations; consistent findings from multiple observational studies), 64 (27.1%) Level C (single or few observational studies or multiples studies with inconsistent findings or major limitations), 15 (6.4%) Level D (expert opinion, case reports, reasoning from first principles), and 20 (8.5%) Level X (exceptional situations in which validating studies cannot be performed and there is a clear preponderance of benefit or harm). Eighty-two (34.7%) recommendations are Strong, 117 (49.6%) Moderate, and 37 (15.7%) Weak. Fifty of the 117 (42.7%) Moderate Recommendations are based on Level C evidence, and 10 of the 80 (13%) Strong Recommendations are based on Level X evidence. CONCLUSION: A minority of recommendations in the AAP's current clinical practice guidelines (10.6%) are based on the highest-quality evidence. Additional research is needed to improve the quality of evidence supporting pediatric clinical practice guidelines.

来源:Pediatrics,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Matheny Antommaria AH, Kelleher M, Peterson RJ, et al. Quality of Evidence and Strength of Recommendations in American Academy of Pediatrics' Guidelines. Pediatrics. 2025. PMID: 40064313. doi:10.1542/peds.2024-067836

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。