儿童与青少年健康伙伴关系儿科整合照护模式的实施:混合方法过程评估
该研究对CYPHP整合照护模式开展混合方法过程评估,该模式在伦敦南部两个内城区以整群随机对照试验大规模实施,涉及近98 000名儿童。链接数据来自73 000名参与者,定性数据包括102次访谈和观察。实施程度因资源可及性、竞争性优先事项和时间推移的自然变化而异;成功的实施驱动因素包括紧密的跨专业与伙伴关系协作。结论认为儿童整合照护可大规模实施,但变异性(尤其是低覆盖)可能限制人群层面的可测量影响。
要点
- CYPHP整合照护模式可在近98 000名儿童中大规模实施。
- 实施程度受资源、竞争性优先事项和时间变化影响。
- 低覆盖等变异性可能限制人群层面的可测量影响。
核心结论
- 儿童整合照护可大规模实施,但实施变异性(尤其是低覆盖)可能限制人群层面的可测量影响。
- 显著的健康系统强化、实施可塑性和情境定制对确保有效且可持续的儿童整合照护至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法过程评估,嵌套于在伦敦南部两个内城区开展的实用整群随机对照试验。
- 试验涉及近98 000名儿童,链接数据来自73 000名参与者。
- 定性数据通过102次访谈(小组和一对一)和观察收集。
- 采用RE-AIM实施框架的五个域(覆盖、有效性、采纳、实施和维持)作为主要结局测量。
主要发现
- 实施程度因资源可及性、竞争性优先事项和时间推移的自然变化而异。
- 成功的实施驱动因素包括紧密的跨专业与伙伴关系协作。
关键数值与推荐
- 干预包括由儿科医生和全科医生提供的本地儿童健康诊所、针对示踪病症(哮喘、湿疹和便秘)的护士主导早期干预服务、决策支持、初级保健热线、自我管理支持和健康促进。
临床怎么用
- 实施儿童整合照护时需考虑资源可及性和竞争性优先事项对实施变异性的影响。
- 促进紧密的跨专业与伙伴关系协作可作为成功的实施驱动因素。
- 需重视健康系统强化、实施可塑性和情境定制以提升有效性和可持续性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: A process evaluation of the Children and Young People's Health Partnership (CYPHP) model of integrated care for the interpretation of trial findings and building evidence on the implementation of integrated care for children. DESIGN: A mixed-methods process evaluation. SETTING: CYPHP was implemented at scale across two inner-city London boroughs in South London, England, as a pragmatic cluster-randomised controlled trial involving nearly 98 000 children, with a nested process evaluation. PARTICIPANTS: Linked data were available from 73 000 participants. Qualitative data collection was through 102 interviews (group and 1:1) and observations. INTERVENTIONS: Local child health clinics delivered by paediatricians and general practitioners and a nurse-led early intervention service for children with tracer conditions (asthma, eczema and constipation), decision support, a primary care hotline, self-management support and health promotion. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Five domains of the RE-AIM implementation framework: Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation and Maintenance. RESULTS: Implementation varied depending on resource availability, competing priorities and natural changes over time. Successful implementation drivers included cohesive interprofessional and partnership collaboration. CONCLUSIONS: Integrated care for children can be implemented at scale, but variability, particularly low reach, may limit measurable impact at the population level. Significant health system strengthening, implementation plasticity and contextual tailoring are crucial for ensuring the efficacy and sustainability of impactful integrated care for children. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT03461848.
引用
- Satherley RM, Newham J, Cecil E, et al. Implementation of the children and young people's health partnership model of paediatric integrated care: a mixed-methods process evaluation. Arch Dis Child. 2025. PMID: 39904570. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2024-327664
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。