新生儿研究中家长参与与拒绝动机:美国多元家长访谈见解
该研究对44名被邀请参与新生儿研究的家长进行半结构化质性访谈,描述其参与和拒绝的动机。利他主义是参与的重要原因,部分家长希望研究惠及其婴儿;参与对家庭的负担(如随访交通)常是拒绝的决定因素,感知婴儿风险、担心被当「实验品」及历史虐待和制度性种族主义也被提及。
要点
- 利他主义是家长同意参与新生儿研究的重要动机。
- 参与对家庭的负担(如随访交通)常是拒绝的决定因素。
- 家长常不区分基线风险与研究参与增加的增量风险。
核心结论
- 在多元家长样本中识别出参与和拒绝新生儿研究的动机,可作为未来干预的靶点。
研究设计与样本
- 对44名被邀请参与新生儿研究的家长进行半结构化质性访谈。
主要发现
- 利他主义是家长选择参与的重要原因,部分家长希望研究惠及其婴儿。
- 参与对家庭的负担(如随访交通)常是拒绝参与的决定因素。
- 感知婴儿风险是拒绝原因,但家长常不区分基线风险与参与研究的增量风险。
- 担心婴儿被当作「实验品」在拒绝者中常见。
- 部分少数族裔拒绝者报告历史虐待和制度性种族主义是重要担忧。
临床怎么用
- 招募时应肯定利他动机,并尽可能消除或减轻参与对家庭的负担。
- 沟通风险时需帮助家长区分基线风险与研究参与的增量风险。
- 对少数族裔家长应承认历史虐待和制度性种族主义担忧。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe parents' motivations for and against participation in neonatal research, including the views of those who declined participation. STUDY DESIGN: We performed 44 semi-structured, qualitative interviews of parents approached for neonatal research. Here we describe their motivations for and against participation. RESULTS: Altruism was an important reason parents chose to participate. Some hoped participation in research would benefit their infant. Burdens of participation to the family, such as transportation to follow up (distinct from risks/burdens to the infant), were often deciding factors among those who declined participation. Perceived risks to the infant were reasons against participation, but parents often did not differentiate between baseline risks and incremental risk of study participation. Concerns regarding their infant being treated like a "guinea pig" were common among those who declined. Finally, historical abuses and institutional racism were reported as important concerns by some research decliners from minoritized populations. CONCLUSIONS: Within a diverse sample of parents approached to enroll their infant in neonatal research, motivations for and against participation emerged, which may be targets of future interventions. These motivations included reasons for participation which we may hope to encourage, such as altruism. They also included reasons against participation, which we may hope to, as feasible, eliminate, mitigate, or at least acknowledge. These findings can help clinical trialists, regulators, and funders attempting to improve neonatal research recruitment processes.
引用
- Weiss EM, Donohue PK, Wootton SH, et al. Motivations for and against Participation in Neonatal Research: Insights from Interviews of Diverse Parents Approached for Neonatal Research in the United States. J Pediatr. 2024. PMID: 38492913. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2024.113923
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。