结核病母亲所生婴儿的管理:系统综述与共识实践指南
同时评估16部国家和国际指南,由不同流行病学背景的国际专家组制定共识实践指南,形成两套管理流程:一套针对分娩时被认为可能具有传染性的母亲所生婴儿,另一套针对分娩时不被认为具有传染性的母亲所生婴儿,并分别对高和低结核病发病率环境给出不同指导。
要点
- 仅3项研究符合纳入标准,现有证据不足以得出循证结论。
- 共识指南基于16部指南和國際专家组意见制定。
- 按母亲分娩时是否可能具有传染性分为两套管理流程。
核心结论
- 结核病母亲所生婴儿的已发表证据有限,无法据此得出循证结论。
- 国际专家组基于16部指南制定共识实践指南,形成两套管理流程,分别针对分娩时母亲被认为可能具有传染性和不被认为具有传染性的婴儿。
- 两套流程均对高和低结核病发病率环境给出不同指导。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入报告结核病母亲所生婴儿管理和结局的原创研究,521篇文献中仅3项符合纳入标准。
- 同时评估16部国家和国际指南,由来自不同流行病学背景的国际专家组制定共识实践指南。
主要发现
- 3项纳入研究因范围窄、目标不一、描述性性质、数据收集不一致和高失访率,无法得出循证结论。
- 16部已审查指南具有一致特征,可支持专家咨询过程。
- 开发了两套管理流程:一套针对分娩时母亲被认为可能具有传染性的婴儿,另一套针对分娩时母亲不被认为具有传染性的婴儿。
- 两套流程均对高和低结核病发病率环境给出不同指导。
临床怎么用
- 临床可依据该共识指南对结核病母亲所生婴儿进行更一致的管理。
- 应根据母亲分娩时是否被认为可能具有传染性选择相应管理流程。
- 应结合所在环境的高或低结核病发病率应用相应指导。
局限性
- 仅3项研究符合纳入标准,且因范围窄、目标不一、描述性性质、数据收集不一致和高失访率而无法得出循证结论。
- 共识指南基于专家咨询和已有指南,而非充分的原始研究证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Infants born to mothers with tuberculosis disease are at increased risk of developing tuberculosis disease themselves. We reviewed published studies and guidelines on the management of these infants to inform the development of a consensus practice guideline. We searched MEDLINE, CINAHL, and Cochrane Library from database inception to Dec 1, 2022, for original studies reporting the management and outcome of infants born to mothers with tuberculosis. Of the 521 published papers identified, only three met inclusion criteria and no evidence-based conclusions could be drawn from these studies, given their narrow scope, variable aims, descriptive nature, inconsistent data collection, and high attrition rates. We also assessed a collection of national and international guidelines to inform a consensus practice guideline developed by an international panel of experts from different epidemiological contexts. The 16 guidelines reviewed had consistent features to inform the expert consultation process. Two management algorithms were developed-one for infants born to mothers considered potentially infectious at the time of delivery and another for mothers not considered infectious at the time of delivery-with different guidance for high and low tuberculosis incidence settings. This systematic review and consensus practice guideline should facilitate more consistent clinical management, support the collection of better data, and encourage the development of more studies to improve evidence-based care.
引用
- Hasan N, Nourse C, Schaaf HS, et al. Management of the infant born to a mother with tuberculosis: a systematic review and consensus practice guideline. Lancet Child Adolesc Health. 2024. PMID: 38522446. doi:10.1016/S2352-4642(23)00345-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。