撒哈拉以南非洲六城市哮喘学龄儿童PM2·5暴露来源特征研究
该个人暴露研究纳入撒哈拉以南非洲六城市12-16岁有哮喘症状的学龄儿童,用背包式监测仪和GPS追踪PM2·5暴露。330名儿童中297名数据有效,仅20%监测日低于WHO 24小时 guideline 15 μg/m3。家庭吸烟、燃煤柴做饭和煤油灯与更高暴露相关,学校地面硬化与更低暴露相关。
要点
- 仅20%监测日PM2·5低于WHO 24小时 guideline 15 μg/m3。
- 家庭吸烟、燃煤柴做饭、煤油灯分别与暴露升高23·0%、27·1%、30·2%相关。
- 学校地面硬化与PM2·5暴露降低37·2%相关。
核心结论
- 提供学校地面硬化、增加家庭清洁燃料使用和减少家庭吸烟可能是降低这些城市PM2·5暴露的最有效改变。
- 不同城市需定制干预以优先不同暴露减排政策。
研究设计与样本
- 个人暴露研究,属于ACACIA项目,在撒哈拉以南非洲六城市监测12-16岁有哮喘症状学龄儿童的PM2·5暴露。
- 监测于2021年6月21日至11月26日进行,从周一上午约10时至周五上午约10时,使用带GPS数据记录器的背包式空气污染监测单元。
- 儿童填写问卷记录潜在空气污染来源,暴露通过GPS坐标标记为学校、通勤和家庭三个微环境。
- 采用混合效应模型识别PM2·5暴露的最重要决定因素。
主要发现
- 330名儿童来自43所学校,297名有有效监测数据,分析1109天有效数据。
- 仅227天(20%)低于当前WHO 24小时PM2·5暴露健康 guideline 15 μg/m3。
- Blantyre儿童PM2·5暴露最高(中位数41·8 μg/m3),Durban(16·0 μg/m3)和Kumasi(17·9 μg/m3)最低。
- Kumasi、Lagos和Moshi儿童在学校PM2·5暴露显著高于家庭;Blantyre、Durban和Harare儿童在家庭和通勤时暴露显著高于学校。
- 混合效应模型显示家庭吸烟者存在与暴露升高23·0%(95% CI 10·8-36·4)相关,燃煤或柴做饭升高27·1%(3·9-56·3),煤油灯照明升高30·2%(9·1-55·2)。
关键数值与推荐
- WHO 24小时PM2·5暴露健康 guideline 为15 μg/m3。
- 家庭吸烟者存在:暴露升高23·0%(95% CI 10·8-36·4)。
- 燃煤或柴做饭:暴露升高27·1%(95% CI 3·9-56·3)。
- 煤油灯照明:暴露升高30·2%(95% CI 9·1-55·2)。
- 学校地面硬化:暴露降低37·2%(95% CI 22·9-48·2)。
临床怎么用
- 儿科智能体医生可建议哮喘患儿家庭减少室内吸烟、使用清洁燃料做饭和照明。
- 可倡导学校地面硬化以减少学龄儿童PM2·5暴露。
- 需根据城市特点定制暴露减排策略,学校与家庭干预优先级因城市而异。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入12-16岁有哮喘症状儿童,结果外推需谨慎。
- 监测期为2021年6月至11月,未涵盖全年季节变化。
- 原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Air pollution is the second largest risk to health in Africa, and children with asthma are particularly susceptible to its effects. Yet, there is a scarcity of air pollution exposure data from cities in sub-Saharan Africa. We aimed to identify potential exposure reduction strategies for school children with asthma living in urban areas in sub-Saharan Africa. METHODS: This personal exposure study was part of the Achieving Control of Asthma in Children in Africa (ACACIA) project. Personal exposure to particulate matter (PM) was monitored in school children in six cities in sub-Saharan Africa (Blantyre, Malawi; Durban, South Africa; Harare, Zimbabwe; Kumasi, Ghana; Lagos, Nigeria; and Moshi, Tanzania). Participants were selected if they were aged 12-16 years and had symptoms of asthma. Monitoring was conducted between June 21, and Nov 26, 2021, from Monday morning (approximately 1000 h) to Friday morning (approximately 1000 h), by use of a bespoke backpack with a small air pollution monitoring unit with an inbuilt Global Positioning System (GPS) data logger. Children filled in a questionnaire detailing potential sources of air pollution during monitoring and exposures were tagged into three different microenvironments (school, commute, and home) with GPS coordinates. Mixed-effects models were used to identify the most important determinants of children's PM2·5 (PM <2·5 μm in diameter) exposure. FINDINGS: 330 children were recruited across 43 schools; of these, 297 had valid monitoring data, and 1109 days of valid data were analysed. Only 227 (20%) of 1109 days monitored were lower than the current WHO 24 h PM2·5 exposure health guideline of 15 μg/m3. Children in Blantyre had the highest PM2·5 exposure (median 41·8 μg/m3), whereas children in Durban (16·0 μg/m3) and Kumasi (17·9 μg/m3) recorded the lowest exposures. Children had significantly higher PM2·5 exposures at school than at home in Kumasi (median 19·6 μg/m3vs 14·2 μg/m3), Lagos (32·0 μg/m3vs 18·0 μg/m3), and Moshi (33·1 μg/m3vs 23·6 μg/m3), while children in the other three cities monitored had significantly higher PM2·5 exposures at home and while commuting than at school (median 48·0 μg/m3 and 43·2 μg/m3vs 32·3 μg/m3 in Blantyre, 20·9 μg/m3 and 16·3 μg/m3vs 11·9 μg/m3 in Durban, and 22·7 μg/m3 and 25·4 μg/m3vs 16·4 μg/m3 in Harare). The mixed-effects model highlighted the following determinants for higher PM2·5 exposure: presence of smokers at home (23·0% higher exposure, 95% CI 10·8-36·4), use of coal or wood for cooking (27·1%, 3·9-56·3), and kerosene lamps for lighting (30·2%, 9·1-55·2). By contrast, 37·2% (95% CI 22·9-48·2) lower PM2·5 exposures were found for children who went to schools with paved grounds compared with those whose school grounds were covered with loose dirt. INTERPRETATION: Our study suggests that the most effective changes to reduce PM2·5 exposures in these cities would be to provide paving in school grounds, increase the use of clean fuel for cooking and light in homes, and discourage smoking within homes. The most efficient way to improve air quality in these cities would require tailored interventions to prioritise different exposure-reduction policies in different cities. FUNDING: UK National Institute for Health and Care Research.
引用
- Lim S, Said B, Zurba L, et al. Characterising sources of PM2·5 exposure for school children with asthma: a personal exposure study across six cities in sub-Saharan Africa. Lancet Child Adolesc Health. 2023. PMID: 38000380. doi:10.1016/S2352-4642(23)00261-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。