儿科专科培训推荐信中的性别与种族偏见:用词是否影响面试决定?
本研究分析单一学术中心2020年Match中8个儿科亚专科培训申请的1521封推荐信,用语言处理工具统计代理性和 communal 术语频率,偏见定义为术语超出5%。结果显示66%推荐信有代理性偏见,16%有 communal 偏见,19%中性;推荐信偏见与申请人性别、种族或面试邀请状态无显著关联。
要点
- 66%的推荐信存在代理性偏见,16%存在 communal 偏见,19%中性。
- 推荐信偏见在申请人性别、种族或民族间无显著差异。
- 语言偏见与面试邀请状态无显著关联。
核心结论
- 儿科亚专科培训推荐信中代理性和 communal 术语的频率未影响面试邀请决定。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究分析单一学术中心2020年Match中8个儿科亚专科培训的1521封推荐信,来自409名申请人。
主要发现
- 66%推荐信有代理性偏见,16%有 communal 偏见,19%中性。
- 申请人性别间代理性偏见无差异(女性67% vs 男性62%;P = .058)。
- 申请人种族或民族间代理性偏见无差异(非URM 65% vs URM 67%;P = .660)。
- 控制申请其他组成部分和人口学特征后,推荐信语言偏见与面试状态无显著关联。
关键数值与推荐
- 偏见定义为推荐信中代理性或 communal 术语超出5%。
临床怎么用
- 提高对儿科专科培训选拔过程中潜在偏见领域的认识,可能促进更公平和全面的申请审查。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To describe linguistic differences in letters of recommendation (LORs) for pediatric fellowship candidates based on applicant and letter writer demographics and to examine if these differences influenced the decision to interview a candidate for a fellowship position. STUDY DESIGN: LORs for applicants to 8 pediatric subspecialty fellowships at a single academic center from the 2020 Match were analyzed in this cross-sectional study. Frequency of validated agentic and communal terms in each letter were determined by a language processing web application. Bias was determined as having a >5% surplus of agentic or communal terms. RESULTS: We analyzed 1521 LORs from 409 applicants: 69% were women, 28% were under-represented minorities in medicine (URM), and 50% were invited to interview. Overall, 66% of LORs were agentic biased, 16% communal biased, and 19% neutral. There was no difference in bias in LORs by an applicant's gender (woman 67% agentic vs man 62% agentic; P = .058), race, or ethnicity (non-URM 65% agentic vs URM 67% agentic; P = .660). Despite a lower frequency of agentic terms in LORs for applicants invited for interviews, when accounting for other components of an application and applicant demographics, no significant association was made between language bias in LORs and fellowship interview status. CONCLUSIONS: The frequency of agentic and communal terms in LORs for pediatric subspecialty fellowship candidates were not found to influence the decision to invite a candidate to interview. However, raising awareness of potential areas of bias within the pediatric fellowship selection process might lead to a more equitable and holistic approach to application review.
引用
- Boolchandani H, Chen L, Elder RW, et al. Identifying Gender and Racial Bias in Pediatric Fellowship Letters of Recommendation: Do Word Choices Influence Interview Decisions? J Pediatr. 2023. PMID: 37995931. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2023.113843
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。