婴儿体位与针芯拔除时机对新生儿腰椎穿刺成功率的影响(NeoCLEAR)
NeoCLEAR 是在英国 21 个新生儿与产科单位开展的一项开放标签、2×2 析因随机对照试验,纳入矫正胎龄 27+0 至 44+0 周、体重≥1000 g 且需腰椎穿刺的新生儿。坐位还与更少血氧饱和度下降相关。
要点
- 坐位较卧位提高首次腰椎穿刺成功率,NNT=16。
- 早期与晚期拔除针芯对首次穿刺成功率无显著影响。
- 坐位穿刺时血氧饱和度下降更少,安全性可接受。
核心结论
- 坐位较卧位可提高新生儿首次腰椎穿刺成功率,且安全性可接受。
- 针芯拔除时机(早期 vs 晚期)对首次腰椎穿刺成功率无显著影响。
研究设计与样本
- NeoCLEAR 为开放标签、2×2 析因、随机对照试验,在英国 21 个新生儿与产科单位开展。
- 纳入矫正胎龄 27+0 至 44+0 周、体重≥1000 g 且需腰椎穿刺的新生儿,随机分配至坐位+早期拔针芯、坐位+晚期拔针芯、卧位+早期拔针芯或卧位+晚期拔针芯四组。
- 共 1082 例随机分配,1076 例纳入改良意向性分析;961 例(89%)为足月儿,936 例(87%)年龄小于 3 天。
主要发现
- 坐位+晚期拔针芯组有 1 例婴儿在腰椎穿刺后 2 天出现阴囊血肿,被认为可能与腰椎穿刺相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要和次要(包括安全性)结局按随机分组进行改良意向性分析,排除数据收集前退出或未进行腰椎穿刺的婴儿。
临床怎么用
- 新生儿腰椎穿刺可优先采用坐位以提高首次穿刺成功率并减少血氧饱和度下降。
- 针芯拔除时机可根据操作者习惯选择,无需强制早期拔除。
- 该结论主要适用于足月且小于 3 天的新生儿,其他人群需进一步研究。
局限性
- 研究主要纳入足月且小于 3 天的新生儿,其他新生儿人群的外推性有限。
- 为开放标签设计,但实验室人员对分组设盲。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Newborn infants are the highest-risk age group for bacterial meningitis. Lumbar punctures are therefore frequently performed in neonates, but success rates are low (50-60%). In Neonatal Champagne Lumbar punctures Every time-A Randomised Controlled Trial (NeoCLEAR), we sought to optimise infant lumbar puncture by evaluating two modifications to traditional technique: sitting position versus lying down and early stylet removal (stylet removal after transecting the subcutaneous tissue) versus late stylet removal. METHODS: NeoCLEAR was an open-label, 2 × 2 factorial, randomised, controlled trial, conducted in 21 UK neonatal and maternity units. Infants requiring lumbar puncture at 27+0 to 44+0 weeks corrected gestational age and weighing 1000 g or more were randomly assigned (1:1:1:1) to sitting position and early stylet removal, sitting position and late stylet removal, lying position and early stylet removal, or lying position and late stylet removal using a 24/7, web-based, secure, central randomisation system. Block randomisation was stratified within site by corrected gestational age (27+0 to 31+6 weeks, 32+0 to 36+6 weeks, 37+0 to 40+6 weeks, or 41+0 to 44+0 weeks), using variable block sizes of four and eight with equal frequency. Laboratory staff were masked to allocation. The primary outcome was successful first lumbar puncture, defined as obtaining a cerebrospinal fluid sample with a red blood cell count of less than 10 000 cells per μL. The primary and secondary (including safety) outcomes were analysed by the groups to which infants were assigned regardless of deviation from the protocol or allocation received, but with exclusion of infants who were withdrawn before data collection or who did not undergo lumbar puncture (modified intention-to-treat analysis). This study is registered with ISRCTN, ISRCTN14040914. FINDINGS: Between Aug 3, 2018, and Aug 31, 2020, 1082 infants were randomly assigned to sitting (n=546) or lying (n=536), and early (n=549) or late (n=533) stylet removal. 1076 infants were followed-up until discharge and included in the modified intention-to-treat analysis. 961 (89%) infants were term, and 936 (87%) were younger than 3 days. Successful first lumbar puncture was more frequently observed in sitting than in lying position (346 [63·7%] of 543 vs 307 [57·6%] of 533; adjusted risk ratio 1·10 [95% CI 1·01 to 1·21], p=0·029; number needed to treat=16). Timing of stylet removal had no discernible effect on the primary outcome (338 [62·0%] of 545 infants in the early stylet removal group and 315 [59·3%] of 531 in the late stylet removal group had a successful first lumbar puncture; adjusted risk ratio 1·04 [95% CI 0·94-1·15], p=0·45). Sitting was associated with fewer desaturations than was lying (median lowest oxygen saturations during first lumbar puncture 93% [IQR 89-96] vs 90% [85-94]; median difference 3·0% [2·1-3·9], p<0·0001). One infant from the sitting plus late stylet removal group developed a scrotal haematoma 2 days after lumbar puncture, which was deemed to be possibly related to lumbar puncture. INTERPRETATION: NeoCLEAR is the largest trial investigating paediatric lumbar puncture so far. Success rates were improved when sitting rather than lying. Sitting lumbar puncture is safe, cost neutral, and well tolerated. We predominantly recruited term neonates younger than 3 days; other populations warrant further study. Neonatal lumbar puncture is commonly performed worldwide; these results therefore strongly support the widespread adoption of sitting technique for neonatal lumbar puncture. FUNDING: UK National Institute for Health and Care Research.
引用
- Marshall ASJ, Scrivens A, Bell JL, et al. Assessment of infant position and timing of stylet removal to improve lumbar puncture success in neonates (NeoCLEAR): an open-label, 2 × 2 factorial, randomised, controlled trial. Lancet Child Adolesc Health. 2022. PMID: 36460015. doi:10.1016/S2352-4642(22)00343-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。