文献速递儿童内分泌与遗传代谢

儿童血清IGF-1检测:质谱法与化学发光法一致性评价

[Consistency evaluation of 2 methods in detecting serum insulin-like growth factorⅠ in children].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi · 2022-01-01

该横断面研究纳入115例身材矮小症患儿,比较质谱法(MS)与化学发光免疫分析法(CLIA)检测血清IGF-1及转化为SDS后的一致性。两种方法IGF-1实测值相关性好但一致性差,CLIA值显著高于MS;转换为SDS并去除离群值后一致性可接受。临床可交叉参考SDS,但过高或过低值需谨慎。

要点

  • MS与CLIA检测IGF-1实测值相关性好(r=0.94),但一致性差,CLIA值显著高于MS。
  • 转换为IGF-1 SDS后相关性好(r=0.92),去除离群值后加权Kappa为0.68,一致性可接受。
  • 临床可交叉参考两种方法的IGF-1 SDS,但对过高或过低极值需依赖临床判断。

核心结论

  • MS与CLIA检测的IGF-1转换为SDS后一致性可接受,可互相参考使用,但对过高或过低极值需依赖临床判断。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面平行对照研究,前瞻性收集2020年2月至2021年12月北京儿童医院内分泌科115例身材矮小症患儿血清样本。
  • 患儿中男46例(40.0%)、女69例(60.0%),年龄(8±3)岁;包括特纳综合征37例、足月小于胎龄儿59例、生长激素缺乏症1例及其他病因18例。
  • 用CLIA与MS分别检测血清IGF-1并转化为SDS,采用Pearson相关、Deming回归、Bland-Altman图和加权Kappa系数分析。

主要发现

  • 两种方法检测IGF-1相关性好(r=0.94,P<0.01),IGF-1 SDS亦显著相关(r=0.92,P<0.01)。
  • Bland-Altman分析示两种方法检测血清IGF-1实测值一致性差,CLIA与MS差值的均值为33.38 μg/L。
  • CLIA测定值显著高于MS,差值为43.51 μg/L(95%CI -51.89~118.70 μg/L)。
  • 转换为IGF-1 SDS并去除3个离群值(含1例GHD患儿)后,加权Kappa示一致性可接受(κ=0.68)。

临床怎么用

  • 临床中可将MS与CLIA检测的IGF-1转换为SDS后交叉参考使用。
  • 对IGF-1 SDS过高或过低的极值结果,需结合临床判断,不宜仅凭单次检测结论。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To evaluate the consistency of mass spectrometry (MS) and chemiluminescence immunoassay (CLIA) in detecting serum insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) and IGF-1 standard deviation score (SDS). Methods: This cross-sectional parallel control study prospectively collected the serum samples of 115 children with short stature disorders who were admitted in the Department of Endocrinology, Beijing Children's Hospital, Capital Medical University from February 2020 to December 2021. The serum IGF-1 level was detected by CLIA and MS, and converted to SDS for consistency analysis. Pearson analysis was used to analyze the correlation between the 2 methods, and Deming regression equation was established. Bland-Altman diagram and weighted Kappa coefficient were used to evaluate the consistency of the 2 methods. Results: There were 46 boys (40.0%) and 69 girls (60.0%), aged (8±3) years. Among the 115 cases, 37 were Turner syndrome, 59 were small for gestational age (SGA) at term, 1 was growth hormone deficiency (GHD) and 18 were other diseases. Pearson correlation analysis showed a preferable correlation between IGF-1 measured by the 2 detection methods (r=0.94, P<0.01), and IGF-1 SDS was also significantly correlated (r=0.92, P<0.01). Bland-Altman analysis showed that the consistency of serum IGF-1 levels detected by the 2 methods was poor, and the mean difference between CLIA and MS was 33.38 μg/L. The result detected by CLIA was significantly higher than that by MS, with SDS of 43.51 μg/L (95%CI -51.89-118.7 μg/L). After converting the results to SDS and removing 3 outliers (including 1 GHD patient), the weighted Kappa showed acceptable consistency (κ=0.68). Conclusion: In clinical application, after converting to IGF-1 SDS, IGF-1 detected by MS and CLIA can be used for cross-reference, but too high or too low levels should be cautious about. 目的: 比较并评价儿童身材矮小症诊疗过程中应用质谱分析法(MS)与化学发光免疫分析法(CLIA)检测血清胰岛素样生长因子Ⅰ(IGF-1)水平以及转化为标准差积分(SDS)的一致性。 方法: 横断面研究,收集2020年2月至2021年12月首都医科大学附属北京儿童医院内分泌科收治的115例不同病因身材矮小症患儿血清样本。用CLIA与MS分别检测患者血清IGF-1水平,并转化为SDS。使用Pearson相关分析法进行两种检测方法的相关性分析,并建立Deming回归方程。用Bland-Altman图和加权Kappa系数分析两种检测法所得IGF-1和计算所测IGF-1 SDS的一致性。 结果: 115例身材矮小症患儿中男46例(40.0%),女69例(60.0%),年龄(8±3)岁,包括特纳综合征37例、足月小于胎龄儿(SGA)59例、生长激素缺乏症(GHD)1例及其他病因18例。Pearson相关分析提示两种检测方法IGF-1有良好的相关性(r=0.94,P<0.01),换算成IGF-1 SDS仍然有良好的相关性(r=0.92,P<0.01)。Bland-Altman分析两种方法检测的血清IGF-1实测值一致性差,所测差值的均值为33.38 μg/L,CLIA测定值显著高于MS检测结果,差值为43.51 μg/L(95%CI -51.89~118.70 μg/L)。转换为IGF-1 SDS,去除3个离群值后(其中包括1例GHD患儿),加权Kappa提示一致性好(κ=0.68)。 结论: 临床应用中MS与CLIA检测的IGF-1转换为IGF-1 SDS后一致性好,可互相参考使用,但是对过高或者过低极值需依赖临床判断。.

来源:Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chen JJ, Gao XY, Cao BY, et al. [Consistency evaluation of 2 methods in detecting serum insulin-like growth factorⅠ in children]. Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi. 2022. PMID: 35922188. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112140-20220112-00041

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。