家长评估儿童生命体征的能力有限
这项对照研究纳入203对儿童-家长配对,评估家长测量儿童心率和呼吸频率的准确性。家长通过触诊、听诊及两种智能手机光电容积脉搏波应用程序测量心率,通过观察和点击应用程序测量呼吸频率,并以心电图和医护人员60秒计数为金标准。结果显示家长低估触诊心率(偏倚-18次/分),呼吸频率测量准确性低,对呼吸增快的敏感性仅37%,提示远程评估不应依赖家长测量的生命体征。
要点
- 家长触诊心率平均低估18次/分,听诊和智能手机应用均未提高准确性。
- 家长测量呼吸频率准确性低,识别呼吸增快的敏感性仅37%。
- 数字远程评估儿童不应依赖家长测量的生命体征。
核心结论
- 家长无法准确评估儿童的心率和呼吸频率。
- 数字远程评估儿童不应依赖家长测量的生命体征。
研究设计与样本
- 对照研究纳入203对儿童-家长配对。
- 家长用触诊、听诊和两种智能手机光电容积脉搏波应用程序测量心率,通过观察和点击应用程序测量呼吸频率。
- 金标准为心电图测心率,医护人员计数60秒测呼吸频率。
- 采用Bland-Altman图及95%一致性界限分析。
主要发现
- 触诊测心率偏倚-18次/分(SD 19),一致性界限-56至19次/分。
- 听诊测心率一致性界限-53至46次/分。
- 智能手机应用程序未提高测量准确性。
- 幼儿呼吸频率偏倚-0.8次/分(SD 9.8),一致性界限-20至19次/分;年长儿偏倚0.9次/分(SD 7.4),一致性界限6至15次/分。
- 家长主观判断呼吸增快的敏感性37%(95%CI 25%-51%)。
临床怎么用
- 远程医疗中不应依赖家长测量的心率和呼吸频率作为决策依据。
- 需开发更可靠的儿童生命体征远程评估工具或方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate parents' ability to accurately assess their child's heart and respiratory rates (RRs) in the context of potential utility for telehealth visits. STUDY DESIGN: In this controlled study of 203 child-parent pairs, parents measured their child's heart rate (HR) using 4 methods: palpation, auscultation, and 2 photoplethysmographic smartphone applications. Parents measured RR by inspecting the child and tapping the smartphone application. The gold standards were electrocardiogram for the HR and the child's breaths measured by a health care professional for 60 seconds for the RR. We plotted the measurements using a Bland-Altman plot with 95% limits of agreement. RESULTS: Parents underestimated HR by palpation with a calculated bias of -18 beats per minute (bpm) (SD, 19), with limits of agreement ranging from -56 to 19 bpm. Parents overestimated and underestimated HR by auscultation with limits of agreement ranging from -53 to 46 bpm. Smartphone applications did not improve the accuracy of measurements. The accuracy of parental RR measurements was low. For young children, bias was -0.8 breaths per minute (brpm) (SD, 9.8) with limits of agreement from -20 to 19 brpm, and for older children, bias was 0.9 brpm (SD 7.4) with limits of agreement from 6 to 15 brpm. The sensitivity of parental subjective opinion to recognize accelerated RR was 37% (95% CI, 25%-51%). CONCLUSION: Parents were not able to assess their child's RR or HR accurately. Digital remote assessment of children should not rely on parental measurements of vital signs.
引用
- Pöyry H, Aarnivala H, Huhtamäki H, et al. Parental Ability to Assess Pediatric Vital Signs. J Pediatr. 2022. PMID: 35973446. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2022.08.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。