残疾儿童在严重营养不良指南中被忽视:一项指南综述
本研究评估了国家和国际严重急性营养不良(SAM)指南对残疾儿童的纳入情况。共审查71部指南(63部国家指南、8部国际指南),85%提及残疾但多为一笔带过,仅4%设有残疾儿童专门章节,99%未链接其他残疾相关指南。访谈提示医疗复杂性、资源限制、流行病学认知不足、证据缺乏和整合困难等障碍。
要点
- 85%的SAM指南提及残疾,但仅4%设有残疾儿童专门章节。
- 仅1部指南提及营养紧急情况下纳入残疾儿童的策略。
- 99%的指南未链接其他残疾相关指南,建议多停留在一般性描述。
核心结论
- 大多数SAM指南对残疾儿童认识不足,即使提及,建议也非常有限。
- 亟需更好的证据来识别和管理营养不良项目中的残疾儿童。
- 将残疾儿童更充分地纳入2022年WHO营养不良指南更新可能支持这一弱势群体。
研究设计与样本
- 指南综述:在线检索和直接查询获取英语、法语、西班牙语或葡萄牙语的国家和国际SAM指南。
- 排除区域指南或针对特定患者群(如HIV感染者)的亚专业方案。
- 共审查71部指南(63部国家指南、8部国际指南),国家指南覆盖了大部分营养不良高负担国家。
- 对参与指南制定的专家进行了8次范围界定关键知情人访谈,以了解将残疾儿童营养不良指导正式化的可能障碍。
主要发现
- 85%的指南(60/71)提及残疾,但大多很简短。
- 仅4%(3/71)设有残疾儿童专门章节,其余缺乏将其一致纳入项目或实践的指导。
- 仅1部指南提及营养紧急情况下纳入残疾儿童的策略。
- 大多数(99%,70/71)未链接其他残疾相关指南。
- 纳入残疾儿童的指南大多仅一般性讨论残疾,尽管不同病症儿童常需不同干预。
关键数值与推荐
- 提及残疾的指南比例:85%(60/71)。
- 设有残疾儿童专门章节的指南比例:4%(3/71)。
- 提及营养紧急情况下纳入残疾儿童策略的指南:仅1部。
- 未链接其他残疾相关指南的比例:99%(70/71)。
临床怎么用
- 临床使用SAM指南时需注意其对残疾儿童的指导非常有限,应结合残疾特异性指南进行个体化管理。
- 在营养不良项目中应主动识别残疾儿童,并关注其不同病症所需的差异化干预。
- 营养紧急情况下应特别关注残疾儿童的纳入策略,现有指南对此几乎无指导。
局限性
- 访谈仅8次关键知情人访谈,样本有限。
- 指南仅纳入英语、法语、西班牙语或葡萄牙语版本,可能遗漏其他语言指南。
- 排除区域指南和特定患者群亚专业方案,可能未覆盖部分相关指导。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Children living with disabilities are at high risk of malnutrition but have long been marginalised in malnutrition treatment programmes and research. The 2013 WHO guidelines for severe acute malnutrition (SAM) mention disability but do not contain specific details for treatment or support. This study assesses inclusion of children living with disabilities in national and international SAM guidelines. METHODS: National and international SAM guidelines available in English, French, Spanish or Portuguese were sourced online and via direct enquiries. Regional guidelines or protocols subspecialising in a certain patient group (eg, people living with HIV) were excluded. Eight scoping key informant interviews were conducted with experts involved in guideline development to help understand possible barriers to formalising malnutrition guidance for children living with disabilities. RESULTS: 71 malnutrition guidelines were reviewed (63 national, 8 international). National guidelines obtained covered the greater part of countries with a high burden of malnutrition. 85% of guidelines (60/71) mention disability, although mostly briefly. Only 4% (3/71) had a specific section for children living with disabilities, while the remaining lacked guidance on consistently including them in programmes or practice. Only one guideline mentioned strategies to include children living with disabilities during a nutritional emergency. Most (99%,70/71) did not link to other disability-specific guidelines. Of the guidelines that included children living with disabilities, most only discussed disability in general terms despite the fact that different interventions are often needed for children with different conditions. Interviews pointed towards barriers related to medical complexity, resource constraints, epidemiology (eg, unrecognised burden), lack of evidence and difficulty of integration into existing guidelines. CONCLUSION: Children living with disabilities are under-recognised in most SAM guidelines. Where they are recognised, recommendations are very limited. Better evidence is urgently needed to identify and manage children living with disabilities in malnutrition programmes. More inclusion in the 2022 update of the WHO malnutrition guidelines could support this vulnerable group.
引用
- Engl M, Binns P, Trehan I, et al. Children living with disabilities are neglected in severe malnutrition protocols: a guideline review. Arch Dis Child. 2022. PMID: 35121609. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2021-323303
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。