遗传信息对新生儿科医生决策的影响:一项心理学实验
该研究采用分裂样本实验设计调查美国新生儿科医生,通过4个临床情景问卷评估不同类型遗传信息对推荐 intensive 或 palliative care 的影响。结果显示,包含意义未明变异、预示神经发育损害的诊断或遗传病因的情景均与更倾向于推荐 palliative care 相关,而待回报的遗传检测结果无显著影响。
要点
- 意义未明变异、预示神经发育损害的诊断或遗传病因均增加推荐 palliative care 的可能性。
- 待回报的遗传检测结果对 care 推荐无显著影响。
- 新生儿科医生可能以有问题的方式应用不确定或预示神经发育障碍的遗传发现。
核心结论
- 新生儿科医生对不确定的遗传发现或预示神经发育障碍的遗传信息在决策中的应用可能存在问题。
研究设计与样本
- 美国全国性新生儿科医生研究,采用分裂样本实验设计,问卷包含4个临床情景。
主要发现
- 包含意义未明变异的情景版本与更倾向于推荐 palliative 而非 intensive care 相关。
- 包含预示神经发育损害诊断的情景版本与更倾向于推荐 palliative 而非 intensive care 相关。
- 包含同等严重病理的遗传 vs 非遗传病因的情景版本与更倾向于推荐 palliative 而非 intensive care 相关。
- 待回报的遗传检测结果对 care 推荐无显著影响。
临床怎么用
- 随着遗传检测扩展,临床医生需理解遗传信息在决策中的使用方式并接受适当使用遗传信息的教育。
局限性
- 研究基于假设临床情景,结论为对假设病例的反应而非真实临床决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Genetic testing is expanding among ill neonates, yet the influence of genetic results on medical decision-making is not clear. With this study, we sought to determine how different types of genetic information with uncertain implications for prognosis influence clinicians' decisions to recommend intensive versus palliative care. METHODS: We conducted a national study of neonatologists using a split sample experimental design. The questionnaire contained 4 clinical vignettes. Participants were randomly assigned to see one of 2 versions that varied only regarding whether they included the following genetic findings: (1) a variant of uncertain significance; (2) a genetic diagnosis that affects neurodevelopment but not acute survival; (3) a genetic versus nongenetic etiology of equally severe pathology; (4) a pending genetic testing result. Physicians answered questions about recommendations they would make for the patient described in each vignette. RESULTS: Vignette versions that included a variant of uncertain significance, a diagnosis foreshadowing neurodevelopmental impairment, or a genetic etiology of disease were all associated with an increased likelihood of recommending palliative rather than intensive care. A pending genetic test result did not have a significant effect on care recommendations. CONCLUSIONS: Findings from this study of hypothetical cases suggest neonatologists apply uncertain genetic findings or those that herald neurodevelopmental disability in problematic ways. As genetic testing expands, understanding how it is used in decision-making and educating clinicians regarding appropriate use are paramount.
引用
- Callahan KP, Flibotte J, Skraban C, et al. Influence of Genetic Information on Neonatologists' Decisions: A Psychological Experiment. Pediatrics. 2022. PMID: 35169841. doi:10.1542/peds.2021-052130
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。