儿童器官功能障碍与多器官功能障碍评分系统:PODIUM共识会议
该共识会议系统检索1992年至2020年PubMed和Embase文献,评估危重儿童多器官功能障碍(MOD)评分系统的性能特征。共筛选1152篇摘要、评估156篇全文、纳入54项合格研究,最常报告的评分为PELOD、pSOFA、PIM、PRISM及国际儿童脓毒症定义共识会议的器官功能障碍计数。结论指出现有评分虽显示死亡率随器官功能障碍严重程度和数量增加而升高,但性能差异很大,亟需统一且数据驱动的器官功能障碍标准。
要点
- 最常报告的评分为PELOD、pSOFA、PIM、PRISM及国际儿童脓毒症定义共识会议的器官功能障碍计数。
- 各研究在特定器官功能障碍标准的界值、纳入的诊断要素及计数与加权方式上差异很大。
- 评分显示死亡率随器官功能障碍严重程度和数量增加而升高,但性能范围很宽。
核心结论
- 现有多种器官功能障碍评分用于评估危重儿童病情严重程度,但性能差异大,需要统一且数据驱动的器官功能障碍标准并在大型异质性国际数据库中衍生和验证。
研究设计与样本
- PODIUM共识会议通过电子检索PubMed和Embase(1992年1月至2020年1月)综述儿童多器官功能障碍评分系统文献。
- 共筛选1152篇独特摘要,评估156篇全文,最终纳入54项合格研究。
- 纳入标准为评估伴MOD的危重儿童、评估MOD评分工具性能特征并评估死亡、功能状态、器官特异性或其他以患者为中心结局的研究。
- 数据由工作组成员录入标准数据提取表。
主要发现
- 最常报告的评分为PELOD、pSOFA、PIM、PRISM及国际儿童脓毒症定义共识会议的器官功能障碍计数。
- 特定器官功能障碍标准的界值、纳入的诊断要素以及计数与加权方式在各研究间差异很大。
- 评分显示死亡率随器官功能障碍的严重程度和数量增加而升高,但性能范围很宽。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参考PELOD、pSOFA、PIM、PRISM等常用评分评估危重儿童病情严重程度,但需注意各研究界值与加权方式差异大、性能范围宽。
- 因现有评分标准不统一,临床解读评分时应结合具体研究背景,不宜直接套用单一界值。
局限性
- 所纳入评分虽显示死亡率随器官功能障碍严重程度和数量增加而升高,但性能范围很宽。
- 特定器官功能障碍标准界值、诊断要素及计数与加权方式差异很大,影响评分可比性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
CONTEXT: Multiple scores exist to characterize organ dysfunction in children. OBJECTIVE: To review the literature on multiple organ dysfunction (MOD) scoring systems to estimate severity of illness and to characterize the performance characteristics of currently used scoring tools and clinical assessments for organ dysfunction in critically ill children. DATA SOURCES: Electronic searches of PubMed and Embase were conducted from January 1992 to January 2020. STUDY SELECTION: Studies were included if they evaluated critically ill children with MOD, evaluated the performance characteristics of scoring tools for MOD, and assessed outcomes related to mortality, functional status, organ-specific outcomes, or other patient-centered outcomes. DATA EXTRACTION: Data were abstracted into a standard data extraction form by a task force member. RESULTS: Of 1152 unique abstracts screened, 156 full text studies were assessed including a total of 54 eligible studies. The most commonly reported scores were the Pediatric Logistic Organ Dysfunction Score (PELOD), pediatric Sequential Organ Failure Assessment score (pSOFA), Pediatric Index of Mortality (PIM), PRISM, and counts of organ dysfunction using the International Pediatric Sepsis Definition Consensus Conference. Cut-offs for specific organ dysfunction criteria, diagnostic elements included, and use of counts versus weighting varied substantially. LIMITATIONS: While scores demonstrated an increase in mortality associated with the severity and number of organ dysfunctions, the performance ranged widely. CONCLUSIONS: The multitude of scores on organ dysfunction to assess severity of illness indicates a need for unified and data-driven organ dysfunction criteria, derived and validated in large, heterogenous international databases of critically ill children.
引用
- Schlapbach LJ, Weiss SL, Bembea MM, et al. Scoring Systems for Organ Dysfunction and Multiple Organ Dysfunction: The PODIUM Consensus Conference. Pediatrics. 2022. PMID: 34970683. doi:10.1542/peds.2021-052888D
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。