指南与共识神经外周血管CTDSA

CTA面积法狭窄度评估对颈动脉狭窄分级误分类及血运重建指征的影响

Misclassification of carotid stenosis severity with area stenosis-based evaluation by computed tomography angiography: impact on erroneous indication to revascularization or patient (lesion) migration to a higher guideline recommendation class as per ESC/ESVS/ESO/SVS and CMS-FDA thresholds.
指南 / 共识 · Postepy Kardiol Interwencyjnej · 2023-02-06

本研究对300例拟行颈动脉血运重建患者的CTA面积狭窄度(AS)与导管定量血管造影(cQA)直径狭窄度(DS)进行比较,发现CTA-AS计算导致大量病变被重新分类到更高狭窄等级,从而可能错误地获得血运重建指征或迁移至高一级推荐类别。作者建议在指南明确不同影像模态的狭窄测量方法前,不应基于CTA-AS进行颈动脉血运重建决策。

要点

  • CTA面积狭窄度与直径狭窄度呈非线性关系,51%AS对应30%DS。
  • 使用CTA-AS替代cQA-DS会使无症状「60-79%」和「≥80%」类分别扩大1.6倍和5.8倍。
  • CTA-AS测量可导致大规模错误血运重建指征,需谨慎用于决策。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 有症状病变阈值:CTA-AS计算将76%的cQA-DS「<50%」测量重新分类为「50-69%」组,将58%的「50-69%」测量重新分类为「≥70%」组。
  • 无症状病变阈值:78%的cQA-DS「<60%」测量被重新分类为「60-79%」组,42%的「60-79%」测量跨入「≥80%」类。
  • 总体而言,采用CTA-AS替代cQA-DS使「60-79%」和「≥80%」病变严重程度类别分别扩大1.6倍和5.8倍,而「≥70%」类别增加4.15倍。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 日常阅片和报告中应避免单独使用CTA面积法计算狭窄度作为血运重建决策依据。
  • 对于拟行颈动脉血运重建的患者,建议以导管定量血管造影直径法(NASCET方法)作为参考标准验证狭窄程度。
  • 注意CTA面积法与直径法之间的非线性关系,尤其在临界狭窄(如50-69%或60-79%)时,避免误分类导致过度治疗。

局限性

  • 单中心研究,结果外推需谨慎。
  • CTA-AS和cQA-DS的测量均依赖操作者一致性,可能存在测量偏倚。
  • 研究未报告长期临床结局,无法直接评估误分类对患者预后的影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

INTODUCTION: Despite a growing understanding of the role played by plaque morphology, the degree of carotid lumen reduction remains the principle parameter in decisions on revascularization in symptomatic and asymptomatic patients. Computed tomography angiography (CTA) is a widely used guideline-approved imaging modality, with "percent stenosis" commonly calculated as %area reduction (area stenosis - AS).

AIM: We evaluated the impact of the non-linear relationship between diameter stenosis (DS) and AS (area = π • (diameter/2)2, so that in concentric lesions 51%AS is 30%DS and 75%AS is 50%DS) on stenosis severity misclassification using calculation of area reduction.

MATERIAL AND METHODS: CTA and catheter quantitative angiography (cQA) were performed in 300 consecutive patients referred to a tertiary vascular centre for potential carotid revascularization (age: 47-83 years, 33.7% symptomatic, 36% female; referral stenosis of ≥ "50%"). CTA-AS was determined by agreement of 2 experienced radiologists; cQA-DS (pivotal trials standard reference, NASCET method) was calculated by agreement of 2 corelab analysts.

RESULTS: For symptomatic lesion thresholds, CTA-AS-based calculation reclassified 76% of "< 50%" cQA-DS measurements to the "50-69%" group, and 58% of "50-69%" measurements to the "≥ 70%" group. For asymptomatic lesion thresholds, 78% of "< 60%" cQA-DS measurements were reclassified to the "60-79%" group, whereas 42% of "60-79%" cQA measurements crossed to the "≥ 80%" class. Overall, employing CTA-AS instead of cQA-DS enlarged the "60-79%" and "≥ 80%" lesion severity classes 1.6- and 5.8-fold, respectively, whereas the "≥ 70%" class increased 4.15-fold.

CONCLUSIONS: Replacing the pivotal carotid trials reference standard cQA-DS "%stenosis" measurement with CTA-AS-based "%stenosis" results in a large-scale lesion/patient erroneous gain of an "indication" to revascularization or migration to a higher revascularization indication class. In consequence, unnecessary carotid procedures may be performed in the absence of cQA verification. Until guidelines rectify the "%stenosis" measurement methods with different guideline-approved imaging modalities (and, where needed, re-adjust decision thresholds), CTA-AS measurement should not be used as a basis for carotid revascularization.

来源:Postepy Kardiol Interwencyjnej,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tekieli, Mazurek, Dzierwa, et al. Misclassification of carotid stenosis severity with area stenosis-based evaluation by computed tomography angiography: impact on erroneous indication to revascularization or patient (lesion) migration to a higher guideline recommendation class as per ESC/ESVS/ESO/SVS and CMS-FDA thresholds. Postepy Kardiol Interwencyjnej. 2023. PMID: 36967857. doi:10.5114/aic.2023.125610

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。