呼吸触发非对比非心电门控MRV(REACT)与对比增强MRV评估儿童及青年中心静脉通畅性的六读者研究
本研究回顾性纳入42例儿童及青年,比较呼吸触发REACT与对比增强MRV评估胸中心静脉通畅性的图像质量、诊断信心和读者间一致性。六名儿科放射科医生独立阅片,结果显示除一名读者外图像质量无显著差异,诊断信心和伪影频率无差异,血管分类一致性相似。REACT可在无需静脉对比剂的情况下评估中心静脉通畅性。
要点
- REACT序列无需静脉对比剂即可评估儿童中心静脉通畅性
- 与CE-MRV相比,图像质量和诊断信心总体无显著差异
- 血管正常/异常分类的读者间一致性两种序列相似
关键影像表现/征象
- REACT与CE-MRV的图像质量评分在六名读者中仅一名读者REACT更高(p=.02),其余五名无显著差异(p>.05)。
- 诊断信心评分和临床相关伪影频率在所有读者中两种序列均无显著差异(p>.05)。
- 七支主要中心血管分类为正常或异常的读者间一致性:REACT κ=0.37-0.81,CE-MRV κ=0.34-0.81。
- 汇总读者和血管,65.4%血管两种序列均正常,18.7%均异常,9.8%仅REACT异常,6.1%仅CE-MRV异常。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 图像质量采用1-5分评分(5=极好),诊断信心采用1-5分评分(5=极有信心)。
- 七支主要中心血管分类为正常或异常(如狭窄、血栓或闭塞)。
- 读者间一致性用Fleiss kappa系数评估,REACT κ=0.37-0.81,CE-MRV κ=0.34-0.81。
临床应用与阅片要点
- REACT可作为无对比剂替代方案评估儿童及青年中心静脉通畅性,避免钆对比剂暴露。
- 阅片时注意血管分类的读者间一致性中等至良好(κ范围0.34-0.81),需结合临床。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计。
- 样本量42例,中位年龄5.2岁,人群受限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. Contrast-enhanced MRI is commonly used to evaluate thoracic central venous patency in children and young adults. A flow-independent noncontrast non-ECG-gated 3D MRA-MR venography (MRV) technique described in 2019 as "relaxation-enhanced angiography without contrast and triggering (REACT)" may facilitate such evaluation. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of our study was to compare image quality, diagnostic confidence, and interreader agreement between respiratory-triggered REACT and 3D Dixon-based contrast-enhanced MRV (CE-MRV) for evaluating thoracic central venous patency in children and young adults. METHODS. This retrospective study included 42 consecutive children and young adults who underwent MRI of the neck and chest to evaluate central venous patency between August 2019 and January 2021 (median age, 5.2 years; IQR, 1.4-15.1 years; 22 female patients and 20 male patients). Examinations included respiratory-triggered REACT and navigator-gated CE-MRV sequences based on the institution's standard-of-care protocol. Six pediatric radiologists from four different institutions independently reviewed REACT and CE-MRV sequences; they assessed overall image quality (scale, 1-5; 5 = excellent), diagnostic confidence (scale, 1-5; 5 = extremely confident), and presence of clinically relevant artifact(s). Readers classified seven major central vessels as normal or abnormal (e.g., narrowing, thrombosis, or occlusion). Analysis used Wilcoxon signed rank and McNemar tests and Fleiss kappa coefficients. RESULTS. The distribution of overall image quality scores was higher (p = .02) for REACT than for CE-MRV for one reader (both sequences: median score, 5). Image quality scores were not significantly different between the sequences for the remaining five readers (all p > .05). Diagnostic confidence scores and frequency of clinically relevant artifact(s) were not significantly different between sequences for any reader (all p > .05). Interreader agreement for vessel classification as normal or abnormal was similar between sequences for all seven vessels (REACT: κ = 0.37-0.81; CE-MRV: κ = 0.34-0.81). Pooling readers and vessels, 65.4% of vessels were normal by both sequences; 18.7%, abnormal by both sequences; 9.8%, abnormal by REACT only; and 6.1%, abnormal by CE-MRV only. CONCLUSION. Respiratory-triggered REACT, in comparison with CE-MRV, showed no significant difference in image quality (aside from for one of six readers), diagnostic confidence, or frequency of artifact(s), with similar interreader agreement for vessel classification as normal or abnormal. CLINICAL IMPACT. High-resolution 3D MRV performed without IV contrast material can be used to assess central venous patency in children and young adults.
引用
- Betz, Dillman, Towbin, et al. Respiratory-Triggered Flow-Independent Noncontrast Non-ECG-Gated MRV (REACT) Versus CE-MRV for Central Venous Evaluation in Children and Young Adults: A Six-Reader Study. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2023. PMID: 36946900. doi:10.2214/AJR.22.28893
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。