16,400例研究志愿者脑MRI偶然发现的患病率与特征
该研究前瞻性收集16,400例研究脑MRI,由神经放射科医生结构化报告,并与非放射科扫描人员的自发识别比较。神经放射科医生报告83%正常、13.3%异常无需随访、3.7%异常建议随访;需随访的异常最常见为血管性、肿瘤性和先天性。非放射科人员仅标记<1%的异常。
要点
- 研究脑MRI中约3.7%存在需随访的偶然发现,应重视系统化神经放射科阅片。
- 需随访的偶然发现以血管性(43%)、肿瘤性(21%)、先天性(15%)为主。
- 非放射科人员自发识别异常的比例极低,不能替代放射科医生阅片。
关键影像表现/征象
- 神经放射科医生报告13,593/16,400(83%)扫描正常,2,193/16,400(13.3%)异常但无需随访,614/16,400(3.7%)异常建议随访。
- 需随访的异常中最常见为血管性(263/614,43%)、肿瘤性(130/614,21%)、先天性(92/614,15%)。
- 年龄>65岁志愿者出现异常发现的扫描比例显著更高(P < .001);但在所有有偶然发现的志愿者中,<65岁者更常被建议随访。
- 非放射科人员标记了<1%的至少含1个神经放射科医生报告异常且需进一步评估的MRI。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 研究方案中应安排神经放射科医生对所有脑MRI进行常规审阅,不应依赖非放射科扫描人员的自发标记。
- 报告偶然发现时需明确是否建议随访,并关注血管性、肿瘤性和先天性病变。
- 对年轻志愿者的偶然发现也应重视随访建议,因其更常被推荐随访。
局限性
- 单中心研究,结果外推需谨慎。
- 研究人群包括推测健康志愿者和已知神经系统诊断者,可能影响偶然发现患病率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Incidental findings are discovered in neuroimaging research, ranging from trivial to life-threatening. We describe the prevalence and characteristics of incidental findings from 16,400 research brain MRIs, comparing spontaneous detection by nonradiology scanning staff versus formal neuroradiologist interpretation.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We prospectively collected 16,400 brain MRIs (7782 males, 8618 females; younger than 1 to 94 years of age; median age, 38 years) under an institutional review board directive intended to identify clinically relevant incidental findings. The study population included 13,150 presumed healthy volunteers and 3250 individuals with known neurologic diagnoses. Scanning staff were asked to flag concerning imaging findings seen during the scan session, and neuroradiologists produced structured reports after reviewing every scan.
RESULTS: Neuroradiologists reported 13,593/16,400 (83%) scans as having normal findings, 2193/16,400 (13.3%) with abnormal findings without follow-up recommended, and 614/16,400 (3.7%) with "abnormal findings with follow-up recommended." The most common abnormalities prompting follow-up were vascular (263/614, 43%), neoplastic (130/614, 21%), and congenital (92/614, 15%). Volunteers older than 65 years of age were significantly more likely to have scans with abnormal findings (P < .001); however, among all volunteers with incidental findings, those younger than 65 years of age were more likely to be recommended for follow-up. Nonradiologists flagged <1% of MRIs containing at least 1 abnormality reported by the neuroradiologists to be concerning enough to warrant further evaluation.
CONCLUSIONS: Four percent of individuals who undergo research brain MRIs have an incidental, potentially clinically significant finding. Routine neuroradiologist review of all scans yields a much higher rate of significant lesion detection than selective referral from nonradiologists who perform the examinations. Workflow and scan review processes need to be carefully considered when designing research protocols.
引用
- Rowley, Paukner, Eisenmenger, et al. Incidental Findings from 16,400 Brain MRI Examinations of Research Volunteers. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2023. PMID: 36927761. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A7821
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。