指南与共识技术与安全

国际皮肤镜学会皮肤肿瘤标准在深肤色人群中的验证:德尔菲专家共识

International Dermoscopy Society (IDS) Criteria for Skin Tumors: Validation for Skin of Color Through a Delphi Expert Consensus by the "Imaging in Skin of Color" IDS Task Force.
指南 / 共识 · Dermatol Pract Concept · 2023-01-01

通过两轮德尔菲法专家共识,验证国际皮肤镜学会(IDS)的皮肤肿瘤皮肤镜标准在深肤色(IV-VI型)中的适用性。17名专家参与,第一轮中除「粉色小团块(乳红色小球)」和「无结构粉色区(乳红色区域)」外,所有原始变量达成一致;专家提出修改3项并新增4项(黑色小团块/黑球、毛囊栓、糜烂/溃疡、血管周围白晕),最终形成79项共识条目。结论认为多数原始条目适用于深肤色,但存在需医生了解的差异点,描述性与比喻性术语之间无显著偏好。

要点

  • 深肤色皮肤肿瘤皮肤镜评估可沿用IDS的8个基本参数框架,但需注意新增的黑色小球、毛囊栓、糜烂/溃疡和血管周围白晕等征象。
  • 「粉色小团块(乳红色小球)」和「无结构粉色区(乳红色区域)」在深肤色中的适用性未达成共识,报告时应谨慎使用。
  • 描述性术语与比喻性术语在专家评分中无显著偏好,日常报告可灵活选用,但需保持术语一致性。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 第一轮中除「粉色小团块(乳红色小球)」和「无结构粉色区(乳红色区域)」外,所有8个基本参数的原始变量均达成一致。
  • 第一轮专家提议修改3项现有条目并新增4项条目,即「黑色小团块(黑球)」、「毛囊栓」、「糜烂/溃疡」、「血管周围白晕(血管周围白晕)」,均达成一致并纳入最终列表。
  • 最终共识列表共79项条目,描述性与比喻性术语在评分上具有一致性。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 在深肤色(IV-VI型)皮肤肿瘤皮肤镜检查中,可沿用IDS的8个基本参数框架进行结构化描述。
  • 报告时应纳入共识新增的黑色小球、毛囊栓、糜烂/溃疡和血管周围白晕等征象,并谨慎使用粉色小团块和无结构粉色区。
  • 描述性与比喻性术语均可使用,但建议在同一报告中保持术语体系一致,避免混淆。

局限性

  • 仅17名专家参与共识,样本量较小,代表性有限。
  • 采用德尔菲法专家共识而非临床验证研究,未报告敏感度、特异度等诊断效能指标。
  • 未报告设备、图像采集条件或参考标准,共识结果的外推需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

INTRODUCTION: A structured set of eight basic dermoscopic parameters (lines, clods, dots, circles, pseudopods, structureless, else, and vessels) including a total of 77 variables with corresponding descriptive and metaphoric vocabulary has been released for evaluation of skin tumors by the International Dermoscopy Society (IDS).

OBJECTIVES: To validate the aforementioned criteria for the use in darker phototypes (phototypes IV-VI) via an expert consensus.

METHODS: The two-round "Delphi method" was adopted, with an iterative process including two rounds of email questionnaires. Potential panelists were asked to take part in the procedure via email on the basis of their expertise in the dermoscopy of skin tumors in dark phototypes.

RESULTS: A total of 17 participants were involved. All the original variables of the eight basic parameters reached agreement during the first round, except for "pink small clods" ("milky red globules") and "structureless pink zone" ("milky red areas"). Moreover, during the first round, panelists proposed a change of three existing items and the introduction of four new items, i.e., "black, small clods" ("black globules"), "follicular plugs", "erosions/ulcerations", and "white color around vessels" ("perivascular white halo"). All such proposals achieved agreement, thus being included in the final list, for a total of 79 items. There was consistency between the descriptive and metaphoric approaches in terms of scoring.

CONCLUSIONS: Albeit most of the original items were considered applicable even for skin of color, there are some points of differences that physicians need to know. No significant preference was found between descriptive and metaphoric terminology among panelists.

来源:Dermatol Pract Concept,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ankad, Behera, Lallas, et al. International Dermoscopy Society (IDS) Criteria for Skin Tumors: Validation for Skin of Color Through a Delphi Expert Consensus by the "Imaging in Skin of Color" IDS Task Force. Dermatol Pract Concept. 2023. PMID: 36892378. doi:10.5826/dpc.1301a67

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。