在前列腺mpMRI报告中加入组织学结局数据可改善活检决策
该研究由一位放射科医生报告791例前列腺mpMRI,将每个Likert评分的组织学结局数据纳入报告模板并应用于207例报告,与历史队列及160例无此数据的同期报告比较。结果显示活检比例从58.0%降至32.9%,Likert 3分患者从78.4%降至42.9%,临床医生对此表示欢迎并认为可增加建议无需活检的信心。
要点
- 在mpMRI报告中加入Likert评分对应的组织学结局数据可降低活检率
- Likert 3分患者活检比例下降最明显,从78.4%降至42.9%
- 临床医生支持报告者特异性审计信息,可提高建议无需活检的信心
核心结论
- 将审计的组织学结局数据纳入前列腺mpMRI报告后,低风险患者选择不必要活检的比例减少。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性队列研究,一位放射科医生2017-2019年报告791例mpMRI,2021年1-6月使用含组织学结局数据的模板报告207例,并与同期其他四位放射科医生160例无此数据的报告比较。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 总体活检比例从58.0%降至32.9%(791例队列 vs 207例队列)。
- Likert 3分患者活检比例从78.4%降至42.9%。
- 其他报告者同期无审计信息的Likert 3分患者活检比例为65.2%,含审计信息队列为42.9%。
- 100%的咨询临床医生赞成该模板,66.7%表示在建议患者无需活检时更有信心。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在mpMRI报告中附上每个Likert评分对应的审计组织学结局数据,有助于临床医生咨询患者并减少低风险患者的活检。
- 报告者特异性审计信息可能提高临床医生对无需活检建议的信心。
局限性
- 研究为单中心回顾性设计,主要基于一位放射科医生的报告数据,样本量有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To see if inserting audited histological outcome data for each Likert score into prostate mpMRI reports was helpful for clinicians counselling patients and influenced prostate biopsy uptake.
METHODS: A single radiologist reported 791 mpMRI scans for query prostate cancer between 2017 and 2019. A structured template which included histological outcome data from this cohort was devised and included in 207 mpMRI reports between January and June 2021. The outcomes of the new cohort were compared with the historical cohort, and with 160 contemporaneous reports without histological outcome data from the four other radiologists in the department. The opinion of this template was sought from referring clinicians who counselled patients.
RESULTS: The proportion of patients biopsied fell from 58.0 to 32.9% overall between the n = 791 cohort and the n = 207 cohort. This was most noticeable in those scoring Likert 3, where the proportion biopsied fell from 78.4 to 42.9%. This reduction was also seen when comparing the biopsy rates of patients scored Likert 3 by other reporters in a contemporaneous n = 160 cohort without the audit information (65.2%) with the n = 207 cohort (42.9%). 100% of counselling clinicians were in favour and 66.7% said it gave them greater confidence to advise the patient when they did not need a biopsy.
CONCLUSION: Fewer low-risk patients choose unnecessary biopsies when audited histological outcomes for the radiologist's Likert scores are included in mpMRI reports.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: Clinicians welcome reporter-specific audit information in mpMRI reports which could result in fewer biopsies.
引用
- Stevens, Parchment-Smith, Adiotomre, et al. Does including histological outcomes in a multiparametric MRI report improve prostate biopsy decision making? Br J Radiol. 2023. PMID: 36802746. doi:10.1259/bjr.20220395
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。