全质量DICOM与最小压缩JPEG乳腺X线图像在放射科培训中的比较
本研究比较了全质量DICOM与最小压缩JPEG格式乳腺X线图像在诊断显示器上的质量,由6名放射科医生和6名放射技师对60例筛查病例(22例癌症、38例正常)进行评分。结果显示两种格式在多数技术和诊断方面等效,提示最小压缩JPEG可用于放射学在线培训和教育。
要点
- 最小压缩JPEG与DICOM格式乳腺X线图像在多数技术和诊断方面等效。
- 放射技师在亮度、对比度、动态范围、锐度等方面评价两种格式无显著差异。
- 放射科医生对解读难度、微小钙化可见性等评价两种格式临床等效。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Running online training in mammography interpretation poses a challenge to radiologists and reporting radiographers due to the large size of digital mammograms in DICOM format and limited bandwidth capabilities of the users for image transmission. This study aims to compare image quality between the full-quality with minimal compressed JPEG and DICOM format of mammograms on a diagnostic monitor through the evaluation of radiologists and radiographers.
METHODS: Twelve participants including six radiologists and six radiographers participated as observers in this study. The observers viewed 60 2D digital mammography screening cases (22 cancer and 38 normal cases) in DICOM and minimal compressed JPEG formats on a 5MP diagnostic monitor. A 5-point Likert scale was provided for observers to compare the quality of mammograms between the two formats, with text anchors indicating to one image being significantly better, slightly better or of equal quality in terms of technical and diagnostic aspects. Nonparametric descriptive statistics were used to evaluate the ratings of radiologists and radiographers in different characteristics of mammograms of two image formats.
RESULTS: The DICOM and JPEG images were statistically equivalent through ratings from radiographers in brightness, contrast, dynamic range, sharpness, no significant distortion, no significant noise, and background homogeneity in all mammograms. Similarly, most radiologists rated DICOM and JPEG images clinically and statistically equivalent with respect to difficulty of interpretation, brightness, contrast, dynamic range, sharpness, the appearance of Cooper's ligaments, visibility of subtle microcalcifications, visibility of structures at the margins of the breast. Normal cases were marginally favored by radiologists in DICOM format (ranging from 0.4% to 5.3%) while cancer cases in JPEG (ranging from 0.8% to 7.6%) received slightly higher rating.
CONCLUSIONS: Findings showed that baseline full-quality with minimal compression JPEG was equivalent to the DICOM format of full-field digital mammograms which suggests that this type of JPEG could be used for online training and education in radiology.
引用
- Trieu, Barron, Lewis, et al. Use of Full-quality DICOM Images Compared to Minimally Compressed Mammograms in JPEG Format for Radiology Training: A Study From Radiologist and Radiographer Perspectives. Acad Radiol. 2022. PMID: 36567143. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2022.11.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。