肩关节前脱位盂骨丢失:多中心研究评估最可靠影像方法
这项多中心回顾性研究由9名读者对110例肩关节前不稳患者的MRA和双侧肩关节CT进行盂骨丢失定量,比较多种测量方法的读者间一致性和方法间一致性。结果显示CT PICO技术读者间一致性最高(PCC 0.75),CT与MRA的best fit circle直径和面积方法方法间一致性均达0.9。结论认为CT PICO最可靠,但CT和MRA均可用于评估盂骨丢失,best fit circle面积是 valuable 替代技术。
要点
- CT PICO技术读者间一致性最高(PCC 0.75),推荐作为盂骨丢失定量的首选方法。
- CT与MRA的best fit circle直径和面积方法方法间一致性均达0.9,两者可互相替代。
- MRA best fit circle面积法显著快于CT同法(p=0.031),其余测量时间无显著差异。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The aim of this multicentric study was to assess which imaging method has the best inter-reader agreement for glenoid bone loss quantification in anterior shoulder instability. A further aim was to calculate the inter-method agreement comparing bilateral CT with unilateral CT and MR arthrography (MRA) with CT measurements. Finally, calculations were carried out to find the least time-consuming method.
METHOD: A retrospective evaluation was performed by 9 readers (or pairs of readers) on a consecutive series of 110 patients with MRA and bilateral shoulder CT. Each reader was asked to calculate the glenoid bone loss of all patients using the following methods: best fit circle area on both MRA and CT images, maximum transverse glenoid width on MRA and CT, CT PICO technique, ratio of the maximum glenoid width to height on MRA and CT, and length of flattening of the anterior glenoid curvature on MRA and CT. Using Pearson's correlation coefficient (PCC), the following agreement values were calculated: the inter-reader for each method, the inter-method for MRA with CT quantifications and the inter-method for CT best-fit circle area and CT PICO. Statistical analysis was carried out to compare the time employed by the readers for each method.
RESULTS: Inter-reader agreement PCC mean values were the following: 0.70 for MRA and 0.77 for CT using best fit circle diameter, 0.68 for MRA and 0.72 for CT using best fit circle area, 0.75 for CT PICO, 0.64 for MRA and 0.62 for CT anterior straight line and 0.49 for MRA and 0.43 for CT using length-to-width ratio. CT-MRA inter-modality PCC mean values were 0.9 for best fit circle diameter, 0.9 for best fit circle area, 0.62 for anterior straight line and 0.94 for length-to-width methods. PCC mean value comparing unilateral CT with PICO CT methods was 0.8. MRA best fit circle area method was significantly faster than the same method performed on CT (p = 0.031), while no significant difference was seen between CT and MRA for remaining measurements.
CONCLUSIONS: CT PICO is the most reliable imaging method, but both CT and MRA can be reliably used to assess glenoid bone loss. Best fit circle area CT and MRA methods are valuable alternative measurement techniques.
引用
- Zappia, Albano, Aliprandi, et al. Glenoid bone loss in anterior shoulder dislocation: a multicentric study to assess the most reliable imaging method. Radiol Med. 2022. PMID: 36562906. doi:10.1007/s11547-022-01577-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。