儿科门诊非增强脑MRI的时间驱动作业成本分析:三家美国医院研究
本研究采用时间驱动作业成本法(TDABC)评估三家美国儿童医院门诊非增强脑MRI的卫生系统成本,比较镇静、非镇静和简化MRI三种检查类型。结果显示镇静MRI平均成本842美元,显著高于非镇静MRI的262美元和简化MRI的135美元;各医院间同类型检查成本差异不大,劳动力是最大成本类别和医院间差异的主要来源。
要点
- 镇静脑MRI成本远高于非镇静和简化MRI,报告时需注意检查类型对资源消耗的影响。
- 劳动力是各检查类型最大成本类别及医院间成本差异的主要来源。
- MRI采集时长是影响总成本的最重要因素,优化流程可降低成本。
核心结论
- 镇静脑MRI的卫生系统成本显著高于非镇静MRI,但各医院同类型检查成本差异不大。
- 劳动力是最大成本类别和医院间成本差异的主要来源,MRI采集时长对总成本影响最大。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为时间驱动作业成本法(TDABC)分析,在三个学术型独立儿童医院进行。
- 对象为门诊非增强脑MRI检查,分为镇静MRI(含镇静或麻醉)、非镇静MRI和简化MRI三类。
- 通过流程地图、关键人员输入和直接观察确定活动时间,尽可能使用回顾性电子病历时间戳。
- 计算劳动力、设备和空间三类资源的产能成本率,耗材作为第四类成本计算。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 镇静脑MRI平均基准成本为842美元(各医院范围775-924美元)。
- 非镇静脑MRI平均基准成本为262美元(范围240-285美元)。
- 简化脑MRI平均基准成本为135美元(范围127-141美元)。
- 敏感性分析显示各医院总成本最大影响因素为MRI采集时长。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在报告和沟通中可参考检查类型对应的成本差异,但需注意本研究基于三家美国儿童医院。
- 优化MRI采集流程、缩短采集时长可能有助于降低检查成本。
- 劳动力成本是主要成本来源,人员配置和工时管理对成本控制重要。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入三家学术型独立儿童医院,结果外推需谨慎。
- 成本计算基于回顾性电子病历时间戳和直接观察,可能存在时间估计偏倚。
- 敏感性分析仅针对镇静MRI进行,未涵盖其他检查类型。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. MRI utilization and the use of sedation or anesthesia for MRI have increased in children. Emerging alternative payment models (APMs) require a detailed understanding of the health system costs of performing these examinations. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to use time-driven activity-based costing (TDABC) to assess health system costs for outpatient noncontrast brain MRI examinations across three children's hospitals. METHODS. Direct costs for outpatient noncontrast brain MRI examinations at three academic free-standing pediatric hospitals were calculated using TDABC. Examinations were categorized as sedated MRI (i.e., sedation or anesthesia), nonsedated MRI, or limited MRI. Process maps were created to describe patient workflows based on input from key personnel and direct observation. Time durations for each process activity were determined; time stamps from retrospective EMR review were used when possible. Capacity cost rates were calculated for resource types within three cost categories (labor, equipment, and space); cost was calculated in a fourth category (supplies). Resources were allocated to each activity, and the cost of each process step was determined by multiplying step-specific capacity costs by the time required for each step. The costs of all steps were summed to yield a base-case total examination cost. Sensitivity analysis for sedated MRI was performed using minimum and maximum time duration inputs for each activity to yield minimum and maximum costs by hospital. RESULTS. The mean base-case cost for a sedated brain MRI examination was $842 (range, $775-924 across hospitals), for a nonsedated brain MRI examination was $262 (range, $240-285), and for a limited brain MRI examination was $135 (range, $127-141). For all examination types, the largest cost category as well as the largest source of difference in cost between hospitals was labor. Sensitivity analysis found that the greatest influence on overall cost at each hospital was the duration of the MRI acquisition. CONCLUSION. The health system cost of performing a sedated MRI examination was substantially greater than that of performing a nonsedated MRI examination. However, the cost of each individual examination type did not vary substantially among hospitals. CLINICAL IMPACT. Health systems operating within APMs can use this comparative cost information for purposes of cost reduction efforts and establishment of bundled prices.
引用
- Hayatghaibi, Cazaban, Chan, et al. Pediatric Outpatient Noncontrast Brain MRI: A Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing Analysis at Three U.S. Hospitals. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2022. PMID: 36541593. doi:10.2214/AJR.22.28490
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。