人工智能与放射科医生在腕部骨折X线检测中的准确性比较
这项回顾性研究纳入637例腕部创伤患者(1917张X线片),比较AI与放射科医生对腕部骨折的检测效能。AI敏感度(83%)显著高于非专科放射科医生(76%),两者特异度相似(96%)。AI与医生联合判读敏感度最高(88%),但特异度降至92%。
要点
- AI对腕部骨折的敏感度高于非专科放射科医生,联合判读可进一步提高敏感度。
- AI与医生对舟骨骨折检测敏感度尚可(84% vs 80%),但对其他腕骨骨折敏感度低(41% vs 26%)。
- AI检测腕骨骨折的敏感度为56%,提示不同解剖部位效能差异大。
核心结论
- AI在腕部X线骨折检测中的效能优于非专科放射科医生,AI与医生联合判读可获得最佳效能。
研究设计与样本
- AI软件采用深度神经网络算法,参考标准由三位资深肌骨放射科医生综合初始放射报告、AI结果及两者联合结果确定。
诊断标准与关键数值
- AI检测腕部骨折的敏感度为83%(95%CI:78-87%),特异度为96%(95%CI:93-97%)。
- 初始放射报告(非专科医生)检测腕部骨折的敏感度为76%(95%CI:70-81%),特异度为96%(95%CI:94-98%)。
- AI联合初始放射报告检测腕部骨折的敏感度为88%(95%CI:84-92%),特异度为92%(95%CI:89-95%)。
- AI检测舟骨骨折的敏感度为84%,初始放射报告为80%;AI检测其他腕骨骨折的敏感度为41%,初始放射报告为26%。
- AI检测腕骨骨折的敏感度为56%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- AI可作为非专科放射科医生阅片时的辅助工具,联合判读有助于提高腕部骨折检出敏感度,但需注意特异度下降。
- 阅片时应特别关注舟骨以外的腕骨区域,AI和医生对该部位骨折的敏感度均较低,易漏诊。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计。
- 原文未报告其他明显局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare the performances of artificial intelligence (AI) to those of radiologists in wrist fracture detection on radiographs.
METHODS: This retrospective study included 637 patients (1917 radiographs) with wrist trauma between January 2017 and December 2019. The AI software used was a deep neuronal network algorithm. Ground truth was established by three senior musculoskeletal radiologists who compared the initial radiology reports (IRR) made by non-specialized radiologists, the results of AI, and the combination of AI and IRR (IR+AI) RESULTS: A total of 318 fractures were reported by the senior radiologists in 247 patients. Sensitivity of AI (83%; 95% CI: 78-87%) was significantly greater than that of IRR (76%; 95% CI: 70-81%) (p < 0.001). Specificities were similar for AI (96%; 95% CI: 93-97%) and for IRR (96%; 95% CI: 94-98%) (p = 0.80). The combination of AI+IRR had a significantly greater sensitivity (88%; 95% CI: 84-92%) compared to AI and IRR (p < 0.001) and a lower specificity (92%; 95% CI: 89-95%) (p < 0.001). The sensitivity for scaphoid fracture detection was acceptable for AI (84%) and IRR (80%) but poor for the detection of other carpal bones fracture (41% for AI and 26% for IRR).
CONCLUSIONS: Performance of AI in wrist fracture detection on radiographs is better than that of non-specialized radiologists. The combination of AI and radiologist's analysis yields best performances.
KEY POINTS: • Artificial intelligence has better performances for wrist fracture detection compared to non-expert radiologists in daily practice. • Performance of artificial intelligence greatly differs depending on the anatomical area. • Sensitivity of artificial intelligence for the detection of carpal bones fractures is 56%.
引用
- Cohen, Puntonet, Sanchez, et al. Artificial intelligence vs. radiologist: accuracy of wrist fracture detection on radiographs. Eur Radiol. 2022. PMID: 36515712. doi:10.1007/s00330-022-09349-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。