INDIAMAN-20方案:将IOTA诊断策略应用于胎儿畸形的即时诊断
本研究旨在制定20种重大胎儿畸形的即时诊断超声描述符,并在本中心2000年1月以来回顾性系列病例中验证。所有描述符均能明确识别相关畸形,但4种畸形并非每例均出现参考描述符;部分征象仅在孕中期后显现。作者认为该方法可能有助于培训经验较少的操作者,并可能融入人工智能与深度学习方案。
要点
- INDIAMAN-20方案定义了20种重大胎儿畸形的即时诊断超声描述符,可在单一超声切面上明确识别。
- 所有描述符均能明确识别相关畸形,但4种畸形并非每例均出现参考描述符。
- 部分征象因自然病程仅在孕中期后显现,并非所有征象在孕早期均可识别。
核心结论
- 研究定义了20种重大先天畸形的超声描述符,可实现明确即时诊断,即INDIAMAN-20方案;作者认为使用该方法可能有助于对经验较少的操作者进行针对性培训,并可能融入人工智能与深度学习方案,进一步提升这些致死性或危及生命畸形的产前即时识别。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分两步:第一步筛选符合以下标准的重大畸形:可在单一超声切面上依据一组描述符直接明确诊断、属于产前较常诊断的畸形、代表主要致死性或危及生命且无手术或仅姑息手术可做的畸形;为每种畸形制定超声描述符。第二步在本中心胎儿医学部自2000年1月以来评估的所有这些畸形病例中检验描述符,病例从电子数据库检索;对每个先天畸形-超声描述符配对评估异常与描述符之间是否存在明确关系,即特定描述符在设定参考切面中是否明确识别该畸形(同一描述符不能见于任何其他畸形),以及特定畸形是否在所有病例中均呈现相应描述符;最后结合20种即时诊断的自然病程评估描述符是否适用于所有孕期或仅选择性适用。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 20种即时诊断中,5种涉及中枢/外周神经系统(无脑畸形/无脑叶全前脑?原文为exencephaly/anencephaly、alobar/semilobar holoprosencephaly、cephalocele、open spinal dysraphism、complete agenesis of corpus callosum),5种涉及心脏(左心发育不良综合征、完全性房室间隔缺损、重度Ebstein畸形、危重主动脉瓣狭窄、大动脉转位),5种涉及腹壁(左侧先天性膈疝、脐膨出、腹裂、体蒂异常)或胃肠道(十二指肠闭锁),5种涉及其余系统(3种泌尿系统:常染色体隐性多囊肾病、多囊性发育不良肾、下尿路梗阻;2种骨骼系统:横向肢体缺陷、桡骨列缺陷)。所有描述符均能明确识别相关畸形,而4种畸形并非每例均与参考描述符相关;例如左侧先天性膈疝在42/93例(45.2%)中未出现胃泡位于胸腔。由于疾病自然病程,并非所有征象在孕早期均可识别,部分征象自孕中期起才显现。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,使用INDIAMAN-20方案可能有助于对经验较少的操作者进行针对性培训,并可能融入人工智能与深度学习方案,进一步提升这些致死性或危及生命畸形的产前即时识别。
局限性
- 原文在结论中自述:4种畸形并非每例均与参考描述符相关;由于疾病自然病程,并非所有征象在孕早期均可识别,部分征象自孕中期起才显现;作者使用「We believe that using this approach may facilitate…」及「it may be incorporated into…」的限定语气。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compile a list of instant diagnoses of major fetal anomalies, and to present their sonographic descriptors and test them in a retrospective series of fetuses with congenital anomalies managed at our center.
METHODS: The first step was to identify major anomalies that meet the following criteria: (1) can be diagnosed directly and unequivocally on the basis of a set of descriptors evident on a single sonographic view; (2) are among those more commonly diagnosed in utero; (3) represent major lethal or life-threatening malformations or anomalies for which no or only palliative surgery can be performed. For each of these anomalies, a sonographic descriptor was produced. The second step was to test the descriptors of the instant diagnoses in all cases with these anomalies evaluated since January 2000 in our Fetal Medicine Unit, retrieved from our electronic database. For each congenital anomaly-sonographic descriptor pair we then evaluated the presence vs absence of an unequivocal relationship between anomaly and descriptor, assessing: whether a particular descriptor in a set reference plane identified unequivocally the anomaly, i.e. the same descriptor could not be found in any other malformation; and whether a particular anomaly presented the corresponding descriptor in all cases. Finally, we evaluated whether the sonographic descriptors could be applied in all trimesters or only selectively, considering the natural history of the 20 instant diagnoses.
RESULTS: Of the 20 instant diagnoses, five involved the central/peripheral nervous system (exencephaly/anencephaly, alobar/semilobar holoprosencephaly, cephalocele, open spinal dysraphism, complete agenesis of corpus callosum), five involved the heart (hypoplastic left heart syndrome, complete atrioventricular septal defect, severe Ebstein's anomaly, critical aortic stenosis, transposition of the great arteries), five involved the abdominal wall (left-sided congenital diaphragmatic hernia, exomphalos, gastroschisis, body-stalk anomaly) or gastrointestinal tract (duodenal atresia), and five involved the remaining systems (three urinary (autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease, multicystic dysplastic kidney, lower urinary tract obstruction), two skeletal (transverse limb defect, radial ray defect)). All of the descriptors were found to identify unequivocally the related malformations, whereas four of the malformations were not associated with their reference descriptors in every case. For example, congenital diaphragmatic hernia (left-sided) presented without the stomach in the thorax in 42/93 (45.2%) cases. Due to the natural history of the condition, not all signs were recognizable in the first trimester, some becoming evident only from the second trimester onwards.
CONCLUSION: We have defined sonographic descriptors that enable an unequivocal instant diagnosis for a list of 20 major congenital anomalies: the 'INDIAMAN-20' (INstant DIAgnosis of Major ANomalies) protocol. We believe that using this approach may facilitate focused training of less experienced operators and that it may be incorporated into artificial intelligence and deep learning protocols, further boosting the instant prenatal recognition of these lethal or life-threatening malformations. © 2022 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Paladini, Franzè, Morena, et al. INDIAMAN-20 (INstant DIAgnosis of 20 Major ANomalies) protocol: application of IOTA diagnostic strategy to fetal anomalies. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 36484491. doi:10.1002/uog.26138
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。