联合深度学习分诊与计算机辅助诊断在DENSE试验第二轮乳腺MRI中的验证
该研究纳入荷兰8家医院2901例乳腺MRI筛查数据,验证第一轮开发的计算机辅助分诊(CAT)与计算机辅助诊断(CAD)联合应用。CAT排除950例(32.7%)无恶性病变,CAD正确分类132/285(46.3%)良性病变无误判恶性。联合应用显著减少假阳性病变数(53/109 vs 89/109,P=0.001),提示可降低放射科医生工作量和良性活检数。
要点
- CAT可安全排除32.7%无病变筛查,无恶性漏诊。
- CAD可正确分类46.3%良性病变,无误判恶性。
- 联合CAT/CAD显著减少假阳性,减少不必要活检。
局限性
- CAT在第二轮AUC显著低于第一轮,泛化性有下降。
- CAD的AUC差异无统计学意义,但样本量可能不足。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Computer-aided triaging (CAT) and computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) of screening breast magnetic resonance imaging have shown potential to reduce the workload of radiologists in the context of dismissing normal breast scans and dismissing benign disease in women with extremely dense breasts. The aim of this study was to validate the potential of integrating CAT and CAD to reduce workload and workup on benign lesions in the second screening round of the DENSE trial, without missing cancer.
METHODS: We included 2901 breast magnetic resonance imaging scans, obtained from 8 hospitals in the Netherlands. Computer-aided triaging and CAD were previously developed on data from the first screening round. Computer-aided triaging dismissed examinations without lesions. Magnetic resonance imaging examinations triaged to radiological reading were counted and subsequently processed by CAD. The number of benign lesions correctly classified by CAD was recorded. The false-positive fraction of the CAD was compared with that of unassisted radiological reading in the second screening round. Receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis was performed and the generalizability of CAT and CAD was assessed by comparing results from first and second screening rounds.
RESULTS: Computer-aided triaging dismissed 950 of 2901 (32.7%) examinations with 49 lesions in total; none were malignant. Subsequent CAD classified 132 of 285 (46.3%) lesions as benign without misclassifying any malignant lesion. Together, CAT and CAD yielded significantly fewer false-positive lesions, 53 of 109 (48.6%) and 89 of 109 (78.9%), respectively ( P = 0.001), than radiological reading alone. Computer-aided triaging had a smaller area under the ROC curve in the second screening round compared with the first, 0.83 versus 0.76 ( P = 0.001), but this did not affect the negative predictive value at the 100% sensitivity operating threshold. Computer-aided diagnosis was not associated with significant differences in area under the ROC curve (0.857 vs 0.753, P = 0.08). At the operating thresholds, the specificities of CAT (39.7% vs 41.0%, P = 0.70) and CAD (41.0% vs 38.2%, P = 0.62) were successfully reproduced in the second round.
CONCLUSION: The combined application of CAT and CAD showed potential to reduce workload of radiologists and to reduce number of biopsies on benign lesions. Computer-aided triaging (CAT) correctly dismissed 950 of 2901 (32.7%) examinations with 49 lesions in total; none were malignant. Subsequent computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) classified 132 of 285 (46.3%) lesions as benign without misclassifying any malignant lesion. Together, CAT and CAD yielded significantly fewer false-positive lesions, 53 of 109 (48.6%) and 89 of 109 (78.9%), respectively ( P = 0.001), than radiological reading alone.
引用
- Verburg, van Gils, van der Velden, et al. Validation of Combined Deep Learning Triaging and Computer-Aided Diagnosis in 2901 Breast MRI Examinations From the Second Screening Round of the Dense Tissue and Early Breast Neoplasm Screening Trial. Invest Radiol. 2022. PMID: 36256783. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000000934
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。