轮班工作量对神经放射学诊断错误的影响:大型三级学术中心研究
本研究基于2014-2020年神经放射学质量保证数据库,分析654份含诊断错误的CT和MRI报告。错误多发生于急诊/住院环境(59.6%),以感知错误为主(84%),且91.1%具有临床意义。错误发生时的轮班平均阅片量显著高于无错误轮班(46.58 vs 34.09,p<0.00001),感知错误轮班的阅片量也高于解释错误轮班(49.50 vs 43.26,p=0.0094)。
要点
- 轮班阅片量越高,诊断错误风险越大,感知错误尤甚。
- 神经放射学错误多为感知性且具临床意义,脑血管和脑部最常见。
- 脑MRI和头颅CT是错误最常检出的检查类型。
关键影像表现/征象
- 错误分类分布:血管25.8%、脑23.4%、颅底13.8%、脊柱12.4%、头颈11.3%、骨折10.2%、其他3.1%。
- 错误最常检出检查:脑MRI(25.4%)、头颅CT(18.7%)、头颈CTA(13.8%)、脊柱MRI(13.7%)。
- 59.6%的错误发生在急诊/住院环境,84%为感知错误,91.1%具有临床意义。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 错误轮班平均阅片量46.58(SD=22.37)vs 无错误轮班34.09(SD=18.60),p<0.00001。
- 感知错误轮班平均阅片量49.50(SD=21.9)vs 解释错误轮班43.26(SD=21.75),p=0.0094。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 高工作量轮班时需警惕感知错误,建议对脑血管、脑部等常见错误区域重点复核。
- 脑MRI和头颅CT阅片时应注意避免遗漏,尤其在急诊/住院环境。
- 关注轮班阅片量,合理分配工作负荷以减少错误。
局限性
- 回顾性研究,仅纳入已记录的错误,可能存在漏报。
- 单中心学术医疗中心数据,结论外推需谨慎。
- 未涉及其他潜在混杂因素(如医生经验、疲劳程度等)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Medical errors can result in significant morbidity and mortality. The goal of our study is to evaluate correlation between shift volume and errors made by attending neuroradiologists at an academic medical center, using a large data set.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: CT and MRI reports from our Neuroradiology Quality Assurance database (years 2014 - 2020) were searched for attending physician errors. Data were collected on shift volume, category of missed findings, error type, interpretation setting, exam type, clinical significance.
RESULTS: 654 reports contained diagnostic error. There was a significant difference between mean volume of interpreted studies on shifts when an error was made compared with shifts in which no error was documented (46.58 (SD=22.37) vs 34.09 (SD=18.60), p<0.00001); and between shifts when perceptual error was made compared with shifts when interpretive errors were made (49.50 (SD=21.9) vs 43.26 (SD=21.75), p=0.0094). 59.6% of errors occurred in the emergency/inpatient setting, 84% were perceptual and 91.1% clinically significant. Categorical distribution of errors was: vascular 25.8%, brain 23.4%, skull base 13.8%, spine 12.4%, head/neck 11.3%, fractures 10.2%, other 3.1%. Errors were detected most often on brain MRI (25.4%), head CT (18.7%), head/neck CTA (13.8%), spine MRI (13.7%).
CONCLUSION: Errors were associated with higher volume shifts, were primarily perceptual and clinically significant. We need National guidelines establishing a range of what is a safe number of interpreted cross-sectional studies per day.
引用
- Ivanovic, Paydar, Chang, et al. Impact of Shift Volume on Neuroradiology Diagnostic Errors at a Large Tertiary Academic Center. Acad Radiol. 2022. PMID: 36180325. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2022.08.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。