印度裔儿童骨龄评估:自动法与手动法的比较
本研究从既往研究中提取920名2-19岁健康印度裔儿童的左手X线片,比较BoneXpert自动骨龄与四位训练有素评估者手动GP和TW法的准确性。结果显示BoneXpert与手动评分的均方根误差分别为GP 0.39年、TW2 0.41年、TW3 0.36年,男孩误差大于女孩,GP50(腕骨权重50%)与手动评分一致性最佳。
要点
- BoneXpert自动骨龄在印度裔儿童中与手动GP/TW法误差较小,可用于临床。
- 男孩的自动骨龄误差较女孩大,判读时需注意性别差异。
- GP50(腕骨权重50%)与手动评分一致性最佳,推荐优先使用。
关键影像表现/征象
- 印度裔儿童腕骨骨龄落后,男孩更明显。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 四名手动评估者间评分标准差:GP 0.52年、TW2 0.52年、TW3 0.47年。
- BoneXpert与真实评分的RMSE:GP 0.39年、TW2 0.41年、TW3 0.36年。
- 女孩RMSE低于男孩:GP 0.53 vs 0.39、TW2 0.5 vs 0.47、TW3 0.47 vs 0.4。
- BoneXpert与手动评分最佳一致性为GP50(腕骨权重50%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 可使用BoneXpert自动骨龄辅助评估印度裔儿童骨龄,但男孩需更谨慎。
- 推荐采用GP50模式以保持与手动评分的一致性。
- 注意印度裔儿童腕骨骨龄可能落后,男孩更显著。
局限性
- 样本来源于既往研究,为健康儿童,非临床人群。
- 未报告设备型号、曝光条件等细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Bone age is useful for pediatric endocrinologists in evaluating various disorders related to growth and puberty. Traditional methods of bone age assessment, namely Greulich and Pyle (GP) and Tanner-Whitehouse (TW), have intra- and interobserver variations. Use of computer-automated methods like BoneXpert might overcome these subjective variations.
OBJECTIVE: The aim of our study was to assess the validity of BoneXpert in comparison to manual GP and TW methods for assessing bone age in children of Asian Indian ethnicity.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We extracted from a previous study the deidentified left hand radiographs of 920 healthy children aged 2-19 years. We compared bone age as determined by four well-trained manual raters using GP and TW methods with the BoneXpert ratings. We computed accuracy using root mean square error (RMSE) to assess how close the bone age estimated by BoneXpert was to the reference rating.
RESULTS: The standard deviations (SDs) of rating among the four manual raters were 0.52 years, 0.52 years and 0.47 years for GP, TW2 and TW3 methods, respectively. The RMSEs between the automated bone age estimates and the true ratings were 0.39 years, 0.41 years and 0.36 years, respectively, for the same methods. The RMSE values were significantly lower in girls than in boys (0.53, 0.5 and 0.47 vs. 0.39, 0.47 and 0.4) by all the methods; however, no such difference was noted in classification by body mass index. The best agreement between BoneXpert and manual rating was obtained by using 50% weight on carpals (GP50). The carpal bone age was retarded in Indian children, more so in boys.
CONCLUSION: BoneXpert was accurate and performed well in estimating bone age by both GP and TW methods in healthy Asian Indian children; the error was larger in boys. The GP50 establishes "backward compatibility" with manual rating.
引用
- Oza, Khadilkar, Mondkar, et al. A comparison of bone age assessments using automated and manual methods in children of Indian ethnicity. Pediatr Radiol. 2022. PMID: 36123410. doi:10.1007/s00247-022-05516-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。