英国NHS乳腺筛查项目中放射科医生与放射技师双读乳腺X线摄影的表现比较
该回顾性研究分析2015年4月至2016年3月英格兰所有筛查乳腺X线摄影,比较放射科医生与放射技师作为首读的双读表现。两组在癌症检出率、召回率和阳性预测值上无显著差异;经验超过10年的读者召回率更低、阳性预测值更高。
要点
- 放射技师与放射科医生双读筛查乳腺X线摄影的癌症检出率无显著差异。
- 经验超过10年的读者召回率更低、阳性预测值更高,与专业组别无关。
- 在双读项目中,放射技师可作为首读提供者,不降低筛查表现。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 放射科医生与放射技师的癌症检出率均值分别为7.84/1000和7.53/1000检查(P=.08)。
- 经验超过10年与5年或以下的读者癌症检出率均值分别为7.75/1000和7.71/1000检查(P=.87),与专业组别无关。
- 放射科医生与放射技师的召回率均值分别为5.0%和5.2%(P=.63)。
- 经验超过10年与5年或以下的读者召回率均值分别为4.8%和5.8%(P=.001),与专业组别无关。
- 放射科医生与放射技师的阳性预测值分别为17.1%和16.1%(P=.42);经验超过10年与5年或以下的读者阳性预测值均值分别为17.5%和14.9%(P=.02)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在双读筛查项目中,可考虑由放射技师承担首读,其癌症检出率、召回率和阳性预测值与放射科医生无显著差异。
- 读者经验影响召回率和阳性预测值:经验超过10年的读者召回率更低、阳性预测值更高,阅片培训与经验积累对报告质量有影响。
- 解读本研究结果时需注意其基于英国NHS乳腺筛查项目的双读模式,外推至单读或其他筛查体系时需谨慎。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性设计,仅基于英格兰筛查项目数据,结论外推需谨慎。
- 原文未报告读者间一致性、病变特征或不同设备/序列的亚组分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Background Double reading can be used in screening mammography, but it is labor intensive. There is limited evidence on whether trained radiographers (ie, technologists) may be used to provide double reading. Purpose To compare the performance of radiologists and radiographers double reading screening mammograms, considering reader experience level. Materials and Methods In this retrospective study, performance and experience data were obtained for radiologists and radiographer readers of all screening mammograms in England from April 2015 to March 2016. Cancer detection rate (CDR), recall rate (RR), and positive predictive value (PPV) of recall based on biopsy-proven findings were calculated for first readers. Performance metrics were analyzed according to reader professional group and years of reading experience using the analysis of variance test. P values less than .05 were considered to indicate statistically significant difference. Results During the study period, 401 readers (224 radiologists and 177 radiographers) double read 1 404 395 screening digital mammograms. There was no difference in CDR between radiologist and radiographer readers (mean, 7.84 vs 7.53 per 1000 examinations, respectively; P = .08) and no difference for readers with more than 10 years of experience compared with 5 years or fewer years of experience, regardless of professional group (mean, 7.75 vs 7.71 per 1000 examinations respectively, P = .87). No difference in the mean RR was observed between radiologists and radiographer readers (5.0% vs 5.2%, respectively, P = .63). A lower RR was seen for readers with more than 10 years of experience compared with 5 years or fewer, regardless of professional group (mean, 4.8% vs 5.8%, respectively; P = .001). No variation in PPV was observed between them (P = .42), with PPV values of 17.1% for radiologists versus 16.1% for radiographers. A higher PPV was seen for readers with more than 10 years of experience compared with 5 years or less, regardless of professional group (mean, 17.5% and 14.9%, respectively; P = .02). Conclusion No difference in performance was observed between radiographers and radiologists reading screening mammograms in a program that used double reading. Published under a CC BY 4.0 license Online supplemental material is available for this article. See also the editorial by Hooley and Durand in this issue.
引用
- Chen, James, Michalopoulou, et al. Performance of Radiologists and Radiographers in Double Reading Mammograms: The UK National Health Service Breast Screening Program. Radiology. 2022. PMID: 36098643. doi:10.1148/radiol.212951
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。