文献速递泌尿生殖腹部CT

囊性肾病变CT Bosniak分类:2019版是否优于2005版?

CT-based Bosniak classification of cystic renal lesions: is version 2019 an improvement on version 2005?
PubMed 文献 · Eur Radiol · 2022-09-01

回顾性比较CT Bosniak v2019与v2005对囊性肾病变的风险分层效能及读者间一致性,纳入149个病变(33恶性),五个读者独立判读。两版敏感度91% vs 91%、特异度89% vs 88%,总体一致性均较高但v2019二分类时下降。结论为v2019未显著改善诊断效能及一致性。

要点

  • v2019与v2005 Bosniak分类诊断效能相似,高类别特异度未提高。
  • v2019二分类为保守/消融治疗时读者间一致性下降(0.80→0.71)。
  • v2019中壁厚度是读者间一致性最差的形态学特征。

核心结论

  • v2019与v2005 Bosniak分类诊断效能无显著改善,读者间一致性相似,但v2019在按管理策略二分类时一致性中度下降,可能反映更严格的形态学标准。

研究设计与样本

  • 参考标准为组织病理学或至少4年影像随访。
  • 由5名读者(3名高年资、2名低年资)盲法独立按2005和2019版Bosniak分类判读。
  • 计算鉴别良恶性的诊断效能(将病变二分为潜在消融治疗III-IV或保守管理I-IIF)及读者间一致性(Light‘s Kappa)。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • v2005与v2019 Bosniak分类鉴别良恶性的敏感度分别为91%与91%,特异度分别为89%与88%。
  • 高年资读者间总体Bosniak分类一致性v2005 κ=0.78,v2019 κ=0.75。
  • 按管理策略二分类(I-IIF vs III-IV)时,高年资读者间一致性v2005 κ=0.80,v2019 κ=0.71。
  • v2019中壁厚度形态学特征的读者间一致性最差,高年资κ=0.43,低年资κ=0.18。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • v2019 Bosniak分类未显著提高诊断效能,日常阅片报告仍可参考两版标准,但需注意壁厚度判读的一致性较低。
  • 按管理策略二分类时v2019一致性下降,提示在决定保守或消融治疗时需谨慎,可结合多读者意见。
  • 有一例恶性病变被降级为v2019 Bosniak II类(未进一步随访),提示需警惕降级风险。

局限性

  • 原文未明确报告研究局限性。
  • 回顾性单中心设计可能影响结果外推。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To compare the diagnostic performance and inter-reader agreement of the CT-based v2019 versus v2005 Bosniak classification systems for risk stratification of cystic renal lesions (CRL).

METHODS: This retrospective study included adult patients with CRL identified on CT scan between 2005 and 2018. The reference standard was histopathology or a minimum 4-year imaging follow-up. The studies were reviewed independently by five readers (three senior, two junior), blinded to pathology results and imaging follow-up, who assigned Bosniak categories based on the 2005 and 2019 versions. Diagnostic performance of v2005 and v2019 Bosniak classifications for distinguishing benign from malignant lesions was calculated by dichotomizing CRL into the potential for ablative therapy (III-IV) or conservative management (I-IIF). Inter-reader agreement was calculated using Light's Kappa.

RESULTS: One hundred thirty-nine patients with 149 CRL (33 malignant) were included. v2005 and v2019 Bosniak classifications achieved similar diagnostic performance with a sensitivity of 91% vs 91% and a specificity of 89% vs 88%, respectively. Inter-reader agreement for overall Bosniak category assignment was substantial for v2005 (κ = 0.78) and v2019 (κ = 0.75) between senior readers but decreased for v2019 when the Bosniak classification was dichotomized to conservative management (I-IIF) or ablative therapy (III-IV) (0.80 vs 0.71, respectively). For v2019, wall thickness was the morphological feature with the poorest inter-reader agreement (κ = 0.43 and 0.18 for senior and junior readers, respectively).

CONCLUSION: No significant improvement in diagnostic performance and inter-reader agreement was shown between v2005 and v2019. The observed decrease in inter-reader agreement in v2019 when dichotomized according to management strategy may reflect the more stringent morphological criteria.

KEY POINTS: • Versions 2005 and 2019 Bosniak classifications achieved similar diagnostic performance, but the specificity of higher risk categories (III and IV) was not increased while one malignant lesion was downgraded to v2019 Bosniak category II (i.e., not subjected to further follow-up). • Inter-reader agreement was similar between v2005 and v2019 but moderately decreased for v2019 when the Bosniak classification was dichotomized according to the potential need for ablative therapies (I-II-IIF vs III-IV).

来源:Eur Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Dana, Gauvin, Zhang, et al. CT-based Bosniak classification of cystic renal lesions: is version 2019 an improvement on version 2005? Eur Radiol. 2022. PMID: 36048207. doi:10.1007/s00330-022-09082-x

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。