肝弹性成像的跨平台变异性:四种设备的成对比较
本研究在慢性肝病患者中比较了2D-SWE-SSI与2D-SWE-GE、2D-SWE-Canon及VCTE-M的肝硬度测量值分布。VCTE-M与2D-SWE-SSI相关性最高(r=0.933)且一致性系数为0.920,变异系数低于20%。2D-SWE-GE和2D-SWE-Canon在高值时显著低估2D-SWE-SSI值(13-17 kPa低估21.7%和25.8%,>17 kPa低估44.3%和32.4%)。结论强调不同厂商设备需了解其特定分布以正确解读结果。
要点
- 低值时四种技术行为接近,可用于排除晚期慢性肝病。
- 高值时2D-SWE-GE和2D-SWE-Canon显著低估2D-SWE-SSI值。
- VCTE-M与2D-SWE-SSI相关性最高且变异系数低于20%。
局限性
- 单中心研究设计可能限制结果外推。
- 样本量在不同设备间不均衡。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
This study was aimed at determining whether liver stiffness measurements by 2-D shear wave elastography using GE's (2D-SWE-GE) and Canon's (2D-SWE-Canon) newest apparatus and vibration-controlled transient elastography (VCTE) share the same distribution of values compared with Hologic Supersonic Imagine (2D-SWE-SSI). In participants with chronic liver disease recruited in two university centers from August 2020 to February 2021, liver stiffness was measured the same day by the same operator with 2D-SWE-SSI plus one of the following devices: 2D-SWE-GE (n = 314), 2D-SWE-Canon (n = 311), and VCTE-M probe (n = 812). VCTE-M and 2D-SWE-SSI values shared the highest correlation and concordance coefficients (0.933 and 0.920, respectively) and a coefficient of variation below 20%, whatever the range of values. 2D-SWE-GE had the lowest variations, with 2D-SWE-SSI values below 13 kPa. However, both 2D-SWE-GE and 2D-SWE-Canon exhibited a frank underestimation of the high percentiles' 2D-SWE-SSI values with coefficients of variation of -21.7% and -25.8% from 13- to 17-kPa values, and -44.3% and -32.4% from 17-kPa values, respectively. In conclusion, knowledge of the vendor-specific distribution of values is mandatory for interpreting results obtained with different machines. If all four techniques behave closely in low values allowing excluding advanced chronic liver diseases in larger populations, discrepancies are observed in high percentile values.
引用
- Cassinotto, Anselme, Jacq, et al. Inter-platform Variability of Liver Elastography: Pairwise Comparisons of Four Devices. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2022. PMID: 36050230. doi:10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2022.06.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。