临床医生对考虑既往CT辐射暴露及监管必要性的看法
本研究通过电子邮件对24个国家505名临床医生进行三问题便捷调查,了解其对既往CT扫描辐射暴露的考虑及是否应监管单个患者年度CT数量的看法。
要点
- 多数临床医生在开具CT时考虑辐射风险,但仅少数认为应仅基于医学指征。
- 约三分之二受访者赞成或可能考虑对单个患者年度CT数量进行监管。
- 不同国家临床医生对辐射风险及监管的态度存在较大差异。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 505名受访者中293人(58%)了解现行法规不限制单个患者一年内可开具的CT扫描数量。
- 关于是否应监管单个患者一年内CT扫描数量,143人(28%)回答「否」,182人(36%)回答「可能」,166人(33%)回答「是」。
- 337人(67%)认为辐射风险应成为决定是否申请CT检查的部分考虑因素。
- 138人(27%)认为决策应仅基于CT检查的医学指征。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 临床医生在申请CT检查时应综合评估辐射风险与医学指征。
- 放射科医生可主动提供既往CT检查信息,协助临床医生评估累积辐射剂量。
- 了解不同国家监管态度差异,有助于制定本地化的辐射防护策略。
局限性
- 采用便捷抽样,样本代表性有限。
- 调查仅包含三个问题,可能无法全面反映临床医生的复杂决策过程。
- 受访者多通过放射学和辐射防护联系人招募,可能存在选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To obtain clinicians' views of the need to account for radiation exposure from previous CT scans and the advisability of a regulatory mechanism to control the number of CT scans for an individual patient.
METHODS: A convenience survey was conducted by emailing a link to a three-question electronic survey to clinicians in many countries, mostly through radiology and radiation protection contacts.
RESULTS: 505 responses were received from 24 countries. 293 respondents (58%) understand that current regulations do not limit the number of CT scans that can be prescribed for a single patient in a year. When asked whether there should be a regulation to limit the number of CT scans that can be prescribed for a single patient in one year, only a small fraction (143, 28%) answered 'No', 182 (36%) answered 'Maybe' and 166 (33%) answered 'Yes'. Most respondents (337; 67%) think that radiation risk should form part of the consideration when deciding whether to request a CT exam. A minority (138; 27%) think the decision should be based only on the medical indication for the CT exam. Comparison among the 4 countries (South Korea, Hungary, USA and Canada) with the largest number of respondents indicated wide variations in responses.
CONCLUSIONS: A majority of the surveyed clinicians consider radiation risk, in addition to clinical factors, when prescribing CT exams. Most respondents are in favor of, or would consider, regulation to control the number of CT scans that could be performed on a patient annually.
引用
- Rehani, Applegate, Bodzay, et al. Accounting for radiation exposure from previous CT exams while deciding on the next exam: What do referring clinicians think? Eur J Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35973303. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2022.110468
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。