深度学习算法在创伤X线中检测四肢与骨盆骨折、脱位、局灶性骨病变及肘关节积液的表现评估
该研究回顾性收集14家中心连续3个月创伤四肢与骨盆X线检查4774例,比较AI(BoneView)与放射科医生报告对骨折、脱位、肘关节积液和局灶性骨病变的病灶级敏感度,并由资深骨放射科医生仲裁分歧。AI对四类病变的敏感度均高于医生报告,尤其局灶性骨病变提升显著,但AI特异度低于医生报告。结论认为AI有潜力通过检测初诊漏诊病变来预防诊断错误。
要点
- AI对骨折和局灶性骨病变的病灶级敏感度均达98.1%,显著高于医生报告的73.7%和16.1%。
- AI对脱位和肘关节积液敏感度分别为89.9%和91.5%,亦高于医生报告。
- AI特异度低于医生报告(骨折88%、脱位99.1%、肘关节积液99.8%、局灶性骨病变95.6%),需注意假阳性。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计,仅纳入一家私立影像集团14家中心,外推性受限。
- 以放射科医生报告为对照,分歧由单一资深骨放射科医生仲裁,参考标准可能存在偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To appraise the performances of an AI trained to detect and localize skeletal lesions and compare them to the routine radiological interpretation.
METHODS: We retrospectively collected all radiographic examinations with the associated radiologists' reports performed after a traumatic injury of the limbs and pelvis during 3 consecutive months (January to March 2017) in a private imaging group of 14 centers. Each examination was analyzed by an AI (BoneView, Gleamer) and its results were compared to those of the radiologists' reports. In case of discrepancy, the examination was reviewed by a senior skeletal radiologist to settle on the presence of fractures, dislocations, elbow effusions, and focal bone lesions (FBL). The lesion-wise sensitivity of the AI and the radiologists' reports was compared for each lesion type. This study received IRB approval (CRM-2106-177).
RESULTS: A total of 4774 exams were included in the study. Lesion-wise sensitivity was 73.7% for the radiologists' reports vs. 98.1% for the AI (+24.4 points) for fracture detection, 63.3% vs. 89.9% (+26.6 points) for dislocation detection, 84.7% vs. 91.5% (+6.8 points) for elbow effusion detection, and 16.1% vs. 98.1% (+82 points) for FBL detection. The specificity of the radiologists' reports was always 100% whereas AI specificity was 88%, 99.1%, 99.8%, 95.6% for fractures, dislocations, elbow effusions, and FBL respectively. The NPV was measured at 99.5% for fractures, 99.8% for dislocations, and 99.9% for elbow effusions and FBL.
CONCLUSION: AI has the potential to prevent diagnosis errors by detecting lesions that were initially missed in the radiologists' reports.
引用
- Regnard, Lanseur, Ventre, et al. Assessment of performances of a deep learning algorithm for the detection of limbs and pelvic fractures, dislocations, focal bone lesions, and elbow effusions on trauma X-rays. Eur J Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35921795. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2022.110447
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。