放射科医生在X线片上鉴别佝偻病与经典干骺端病变的诊断效能:一项多中心研究
结果显示,医生对CML诊断的敏感度95.1%、特异度97.0%、准确率96.0%,观察者间几乎完全一致(κ=0.92和0.89)。佝偻病与CML的影像学征象有显著差异,且CML多发生于6个月以下婴儿,而1岁以上少见。
要点
- CML诊断敏感度95.1%、特异度97.0%、准确率96.0%,与儿科或非儿科、经验多少无关。
- CML多见于6个月以下婴儿(89.6%),而佝偻病多见于1岁以上(65.7%)。
- 鉴别要点:佝偻病常见临时钙化带丢失、杯口状、毛刷状、骺板增宽;CML常见角骨折、桶柄状骨折、骺下透亮区等。
核心结论
- 放射科医生在鉴别佝偻病与CML时具有高观察者间一致性和高诊断效能;认识CML多发生于6个月以下婴儿、1岁以上少见可能有助于判读。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性七中心研究,纳入2007年1月至2018年12月期间接受膝关节X线摄影的2岁以下儿童,佝偻病组25名(25-羟基维生素D<20 ng/mL且膝关节X线异常),CML组77名(由儿童虐待儿科医生诊断为虐待所致),由8名放射科医生独立判读。
关键影像表现/征象
- 临时钙化带丢失、杯口状、毛刷状和骺板增宽在佝偻病中更常见,在CML患儿中检出率不足4%。
- 角骨折、桶柄状骨折、骺下透亮区、角变形、干骺端不规则和骨膜下新骨形成在CML中更常见,在佝偻病患儿中检出率不足4%。
- CML组所有患儿在体格检查或其他影像学检查中均发现除膝关节CML外的其他损伤。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CML诊断(中等或高置信度判读)的敏感度95.1%、特异度97.0%、准确率96.0%。
- 佝偻病与CML的中等或高置信度判读观察者间一致性κ分别为0.92和0.89。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 放射科医生可依据上述影像征象可靠鉴别佝偻病与CML;CML多发生于6个月以下婴儿,1岁以上少见,判读时需结合年龄。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. Despite evidence supporting the specificity of classic metaphyseal lesions (CML) for the diagnosis of child abuse, some medicolegal practitioners claim that CML result from rickets rather than trauma. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to evaluate radiologists' diagnostic performance in differentiating rickets and CML on radiographs. METHODS. This retrospective seven-center study included children younger than 2 years who underwent knee radiography from January 2007 to December 2018 and who had either rickets (25-hydroxyvitamin D level < 20 ng/mL and abnormal knee radiographs) or knee CML and a diagnosis of child abuse from a child abuse pediatrician. Additional injuries were identified through medical record review. Radiographs were cropped and zoomed to present similar depictions of the knee. Eight radiologists independently interpreted radiographs for diagnoses of rickets or CML, rated confidence levels, and recorded associated radiographic signs. RESULTS. Seventy children (27 girls, 43 boys) had rickets; 77 children (37 girls, 40 boys) had CML. Children with CML were younger than those with rickets (mean, 3.7 vs 14.2 months, p < .001; 89.6% vs 5.7% younger than 6 months; 3.9% vs 65.7% older than 1 year). All children with CML had injuries in addition to the knee CML identified at physical examination or other imaging examinations. Radiologists had almost perfect agreement for moderate- or high-confidence interpretations of rickets (κ = 0.92) and CML (κ = 0.89). Across radiologists, estimated sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy for CML for moderate- or high-confidence interpretations were 95.1%, 97.0%, and 96.0%. Accuracy was not significantly different between pediatric and nonpediatric radiologists (p = .20) or between less experienced and more experienced radiologists (p = .57). Loss of metaphyseal zone of provisional calcification, cupping, fraying, and physeal widening were more common in rickets than CML, being detected in less than 4% of children with CML. Corner fracture, bucket-handle fracture, subphyseal lucency, deformed corner, metaphyseal irregularity, and subperiosteal new bone formation were more common in CML than rickets, being detected in less than 4% of children with rickets. CONCLUSION. Radiologists had high interobserver agreement and high diagnostic performance for differentiating rickets and CML. Recognition that CML mostly occur in children younger than 6 months and are unusual in children older than 1 year may assist interpretation. CLINICAL IMPACT. Rickets and CML have distinct radiographic signs, and radiologists can reliably differentiate these two entities.
引用
- Karmazyn, Marine, Jones, et al. Radiologists' Diagnostic Performance in Differentiation of Rickets and Classic Metaphyseal Lesions on Radiographs: A Multicenter Study. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2022. PMID: 35792137. doi:10.2214/AJR.22.27729
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。