新生儿镇静与麻醉的使用:SPR 调查
新生儿影像镇静使用率在介入操作最高(93%),其次为MR(85%)、核医学(48%)和CT(31%);各机构实践模式差异大,甚至同一机构内放射科医生之间也不一致,调查强调需提高认识、教育和标准化。
要点
- 新生儿介入操作镇静使用率93%,MR 85%,核医学48%,CT 31%。
- 46%的受访者对全部新生儿MR尝试喂奶和包裹,另46%视情况尝试,多数在镇静前仅尝试一次包裹。
- 89%的受访者知晓文献中的神经毒性担忧并认同其合理性。
核心结论
- 北美各机构新生儿影像镇静与麻醉的实践模式、政策及理解差异很大,甚至同一机构内放射科医生之间也不一致;调查强调需在机构和社会层面提高认识、教育和标准化。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 新生儿MRI镇静:46%的受访者报告对所有患者尝试喂奶和包裹,另46%视情况尝试,多数(35%)在镇静前使用一次包裹尝试。
- 新生儿各检查镇静使用率:介入操作93%,MR 85%,核医学48%,CT 31%。
- 63%的受访者报告新生儿MR镇静平均成功率大于50%。
局限性
- 13/59家机构有多名受访者,多个类别中存在应答不一致。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: There is little data regarding the use of sedation and anesthesia for neonatal imaging, with practice patterns varying widely across institutions.
OBJECTIVE: To understand the current utilization of sedation and anesthesia for neonatal imaging, and review the current literature and recommendations.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: One thousand, two hundred twenty-six questionnaire invitations were emailed to North American physician members of the Society for Pediatric Radiology using the Survey Monkey platform. Descriptive statistical analysis of the responses was performed.
RESULTS: The final results represented 59 institutions from 26 U.S. states, the District of Columbia and three Canadian provinces. Discrepant responses from institutions with multiple respondents (13 out of 59 institutions) were prevalent in multiple categories. Of the 80 total respondents, slightly more than half (56%) were associated with children's hospitals and 44% with the pediatric division of an adult radiology department. Most radiologists (70%) were cognizant of the neonatal sedation policies in their departments. A majority (89%) acknowledged awareness of neurotoxicity concerns in the literature and agreed with the validity of these concerns. In neonates undergoing magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), 46% of respondents reported attempting feed and bundle in all patients and an additional 46% attempt on a case-by-case basis, with most (35%) using a single swaddling attempt before sedation. Sedation was most often used for neonatal interventional procedures (93%) followed by MR (85%), nuclear medicine (48%) and computed tomography (31%). More than half of respondents (63%) reported an average success rate of greater than 50% when using neonatal sedation for MR.
CONCLUSION: Current practice patterns, policies and understanding of the use of sedation and anesthesia for neonatal imaging vary widely across institutions in North America, and even among radiologists from the same institution. Our survey highlights the need for improved awareness, education, and standardization at both the institutional level and the societal level. Awareness of the potential for anesthetic neurotoxicity and success of non-pharmacologic approaches to neonatal imaging is crucial, along with education of health care personnel, systematic approaches to quality control and improvement, and integration of evidence-based protocols into clinical practice.
引用
- Hwang, Barton, Kim, et al. Utilization of neonatal sedation and anesthesia: an SPR survey. Pediatr Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35767032. doi:10.1007/s00247-022-05423-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。