三维MRI与三维CT在肩关节盂肱关节炎盂唇畸形评估中的比较:基于Dixon三维FLASH序列
研究对29例骨关节炎肩关节行CT和MRI(Dixon技术)三维重建,比较盂唇形态测量和侵蚀评估。三维CT与三维MRI的盂唇版本角平均绝对差为2.7°±1.6°(P=0.7),盂唇倾斜角平均绝对差为6.8°±4.1°(P=0.17)。结论认为三维MRI在轴向骨丢失(盂唇版本角)评估上与三维CT相当,但冠状骨丢失(盂唇倾斜角)评估仍以三维CT为金标准,三维MR可作为术前盂唇版本角评估的替代方法。
要点
- 三维MRI与三维CT测量盂唇版本角的平均绝对差为2.7°±1.6°,两者可比。
- 三维MRI与三维CT测量盂唇倾斜角的平均绝对差为6.8°±4.1°,冠状骨丢失评估仍以三维CT为金标准。
- 两种方法对Walch分级盂唇骨丢失的观察者间信度均高(CT κ=1,MRI κ=0.81)。
核心结论
- 三维MRI在轴向盂唇骨丢失(以盂唇版本角衡量)评估上与三维CT相当,但冠状骨丢失(以盂唇倾斜角衡量)评估仍以三维CT为金标准,三维MR可作为关节炎肩术前盂唇版本角评估的替代方法。
研究设计与样本
- 对29例骨关节炎肩关节的CT和MRI(采用Dixon技术)图像生成三维重建,两名评估者独立进行盂唇形态测量和盂唇侵蚀评估,计算两种模态间的平均差异,用kappa系数计算观察者间一致性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 三维CT与三维MRI的盂唇版本角合并平均绝对差(偏倚)为2.7°±1.6°(范围0.15-7.85,P值=0.7)。
- 三维CT与三维MRI的盂唇倾斜角合并平均绝对差为6.8°±4.1°(范围0.8°-15.75°,P值=0.17)。
- 三维CT和三维MRI上盂唇版本角与倾斜角测量均未见显著读者间变异(P>0.05)。
- CT和MRI对Walch分级盂唇骨丢失的读者间信度均高(κ=1,κ=0.81,分别)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 三维MR可作为术前评估关节炎肩盂唇版本角的替代方法。
- 冠状骨丢失(盂唇倾斜角)评估仍以三维CT为金标准。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare MRI with 3D reconstructions and 3D-CT with respect to assessment of glenoid wear in osteoarthritic shoulders.
METHODS: 3D reconstructions were generated for CT and MR (utilizing the Dixon technique) imaging performed on 29 osteoarthritic shoulders. Two reviewers independently performed glenoid morphometric measurements and evaluated glenoid erosion. Mean differences between the two modalities were calculated. Inter-observer agreement was calculated using kappa coefficient.
RESULTS: The combined mean absolute difference (bias) in glenoid version between 3D-CT and 3D-MRI was 2.7° ± 1.6° (range 0.15-7.85, P value = 0.7). The combined mean absolute difference in glenoid inclination between 3D-CT and 3D-MRI was 6.8° ± 4.1° (range 0.8°-15.75°, P value = 0.17). No significant inter-reader variation in glenoid version and inclination measurements on 3D-CT and 3D-MRI was found (P > 0.05). The inter-reader reliability for both CT and MRI was high for Walch grading of glenoid bone loss (κ = 1, κ = 0.81, respectively).
CONCLUSIONS: 3D-MRI is comparable to 3D-CT with respect to axial glenoid bone loss, as measured by glenoid version. However, for coronal bone loss estimation, measured by glenoid inclination, 3D-CT remains the gold standard. Thus, 3D-MR can be used as an alternative for preoperative assessment of glenoid version in arthritic shoulders.
引用
- Rosenthal, Samim, Gyftopoulos, et al. 3D-MRI versus 3D-CT in the evaluation of glenoid deformity in glenohumeral arthritis using Dixon 3D FLASH sequence. Skeletal Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35737085. doi:10.1007/s00256-022-04086-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。